Alemania

Personal Styles

Jesse Simon
---
---
Berlín, viernes, 28 de agosto de 2015.
Philharmonie. Britten: Variations on a theme of Frank Bridge, op. 10. Shostakovich: Symphony No. 4 in C minor, op. 43. Berlin Philharmonic, Sir Simon Rattle, conductor.
0,0002011

As another summer ends, so another concert season begins. Over the next several weeks, Berlin’s various orchestras and opera houses will resume active service, while the annual Musikfest will bring a number of high-profile guest artists to the concert halls of the city. But everything has to start somewhere, and that place is usually the season opening concert of the Berlin Philharmonic, traditionally held around the last weekend in August.

This year’s programme, conducted by Sir Simon Rattle, offered two early works by two of the twentieth century’s great individualists, pairing Britten’s diverting Variations on a theme of Frank Bridge with Shostakovich’s ambitious and controversial Fourth Symphony. The two pieces, written within a year of one another in the mid-1930s, may differ considerably in form, style and character, but both date from a period during which each composer had started to discover their mature voice.

Britten’s Variations, scored for a large string orchestra and written as a tribute to his teacher and mentor Frank Bridge, acts as a compendium of the formal techniques that the composer had mastered while coming to terms with his own style, and the strings of the Berlin Philharmonic were easily up to the work’s challenges. Both the violins and cellos, in the first and fifth variations respectively, achieved a sound that augured well for the Shostakovich to come, and the basses distinguished themselves especially in the introduction, and the section of the final variation after the fugue in which Bridge’s theme makes its full reappearance.

In the fourth variation, a well-played passage for solo-violin conjured distant memories of Vivaldi while, in the seventh, the massed strings managed an impressive, otherworldly swarm. Only at the height of the fugue was there some loss of absolute clarity, but even this was quickly righted. Sir Simon directed the piece with rhythmic grace and a far-sighted sense of the work’s essential good nature. Even in the tragic eighth variation, with its heightened tension in the high strings, and in the contemplative ninth, the work retained its guiding momentum and inventive delight.

When Britten completed his Variations, he had to wait only a few months for the première. Shostakovich, who had completed his Fourth Symphony a year earlier, in 1936, would have to wait for a quarter-century. The reasons by now are well known: Stalin, who took objection to a particularly vigorous passage in Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District, arranged for both the opera and its composer to be denounced in the national press; as a result, the première of the Fourth Symphony was cancelled and the composer, perhaps at the behest of the authorities, withdrew the score. Although he would redeem himself (at least in the eyes of Stalin) with his blustery, ostensibly patriotic Fifth Symphony, the Fourth would remain unperformed until several years after Stalin’s death.

With these historical and political circumstances now long in the past, it has become easier to hear the piece less as a work of musical subversion and, more simply, as Shostakovich’s first great symphonic expression of personal style. On this evening it was given a performance that, while occasionally unconventional and certainly not idiomatically Russian, nonetheless managed to find the threads of beauty and mystery woven into the brooding violence of the score.

The pace of the opening wasn’t exactly slow, but the presiding rhythm sounded deadened, lacking in exuberance and bounce. Somehow, it worked. The mood that emerged from the opening movement had a solemnity, a heaviness that kept the symphony’s wildest elements at bay; what remained was a compelling ominousness. Sir Simon’s deliberate pacing created ample room for the detailed orchestration to shine, and if the strings had demonstrated the breadth of their command in the evening’s first half, the second half was very much driven by the imposing authority of the woodwinds: from the opening bars, the flutes sounded furious and declamatory, and not long afterward an agitated passage for solo oboe captured the full attention of the room. In the third movement, the solo bassoon offered a beautiful introductory figure, and later engaged in an inspired dialogue with the strings; at the end of the evening, it was the principal bassoonist who was singled out for the first ovation, and the applause he received was both considerable and well-deserved.

If the first movement had been governed by an unsettling rhythmic force that presided equally over the loudest and quietest moments, the second movement seemed to trade in some of its perpetual motion for something altogether more introspective. However it was the third movement that would stand as the most impressive part of the symphony and, indeed, the evening. The opening theme was passed between instruments, leading eventually to a powerful passage that, while undoubtedly loud, never threatened to ruffle the composure of the orchestra.

What followed was a thrilling Allegro section in which the orchestra, rather than raging against an unstoppable rhythm – as they had in the first movement – became completely locked into the momentum of the piece. A quieter passage gave way to the stirring timpani that heralded the movement’s grand climax; it was undeniably large, but never reckless. When it subsided, the symphony was brought to a close with an enthralling, slow-burning coda featuring celesta and trumpet emerging cautiously from a bed of violins that seemed to grow more luminous the quieter they became.

Shostakovich may have intended his Fourth Symphony to sound wilder, even uglier than the performance given on this evening, and it is certainly possible to hear recordings where the darker aspects are pushed to the fore. Yet by examining the murkier depths beyond the symphony’s brash surface, Sir Simon and the Berlin Philharmonic offered a reading that was satisfying on its own terms and, in numerous places, hauntingly beautiful. Most importantly, the orchestra demonstrated, as they have done so often before, that they know how to get a new concert season off to an eminently promising start.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.