Alemania
Musikfest 2: Hammer Blows
When Andris Nelsons was last on the stage of the Philharmonie, in April of this year, he led the Berlin Philharmonic through a version of Mahler’s Fifth Symphony that, despite its uneven moments, contained an almost ridiculous level of ambition. In his most recent appearance – one of a number of Mahler-themed concerts at this year’s Musikfest – Mr Nelsons guided the Boston Symphony Orchestra in a performance of the Sixth that toned down some of his more impetuous tendencies in favour of a more tightly-controlled and deeply-considered vision of the work as a whole.
The results were striking, both for their intensity and their lasting effect. Whether or not one agreed with all of Mr Nelsons’ interpretive decisions – and, in stark contrast to Zubin Mehta’s selfless reading of the Ninth the following evening, few efforts were made to conceal the presence of a strong interpretive force guiding the music – the symphony remained gripping for the whole of its ninety-minute duration. It was the kind of performance that forced its audience to engage with the music on its own emotional and intellectual terms, and more often than not it seemed to work.
Mr Nelsons can be a highly theatrical conductor; for all the modesty he displays during the applause, he is a dynamic presence on the podium, sometimes resembling a student of fencing or karate as he leaps, lunges and slashes. Through action and expression he conveys the painful intensity (or ecstatic euphoria) of each phrase, and he has a tendency to generate excitement by suggesting an underlying wildness in the music that neither he nor the orchestra are entirely able to control; this was especially apparent during the second appearance of the Alma theme in the first movement, which seemed to pursue its own beauty to the very limit of reason.
Yet the potential for recklessness was, on this evening, offset by the sense of a clear and tempered vision of the work as it moved toward its inevitable (and affectingly tragic) conclusion. The first movement, with its agitated pace and incisive bass attack, achieved its excitement not through exploring the boundaries of its individual episodes, but by making those episodes subject to a clearly defined rhythm. The approach didn’t always yield uniform results – the quiet section near the end of the movement seemed to have too much residual energy to allow for the necessary mood of reverence – but taken as a whole, it was thrilling.
The following movement – Mr Nelsons placed the Scherzo second, following Kubelik, Bernstein, Boulez and numerous others – took considerably greater risks with its tempi. If the trio sections had been any slower they might have ground to a halt, but whenever the forced rhythm of the Scherzo reappeared it sounded driven to an almost dangerous degree. Despite these extremes, the movement managed to retain a certain coherence, as Mr Nelsons harnessed the back-and-forth pull between methodically slow and compulsively fast to impart an uneasy sense of structure.
Mr Nelsons has been the music director of the Boston Symphony for just over a year now, and the orchestra seemed generally responsive even to the less conventional aspects of his interpretation. The muscular, woody sound of the low strings were a perfect fit for the first movement, and if the trumpets occasionally sounded too prominent, they were balanced by the concentrated glow of the trombones. The opening of the slow movement was elevated by excellent work from throughout the woodwind section. However there were also parts of the slow movement that might have benefitted from more disciplined ensemble playing. Despite a handful of undeniably beautiful passages, one could still discern the anxious demeanour of the first two movements not far below the placid surfaces.
There were few such reservations about the final movement, which seemed perfectly suited to the strengths of both orchestra and conductor. After an expansive opening, the initial episodes unfolded with a resounding sense of purpose; although Mr Nelsons led the proceedings with such vigour that he, at one point, seemed in danger of pushing the back right off the podium, one grew less aware of his directorial presence and more focused on the life-and-death drama emerging from the orchestra.
An extraordinary tension in the strings culminated in the first of the hammer blows which, in this instance, involved one of the percussionists bringing the force of an enormous mallet – closer to a prop from the final scene of Das Rheingold than anything one might find in a traditional percussion section – down upon a wooden box next to the Celesta; the effect was surprisingly terrifying. Yet in the quiet bars leading up to the symphony’s final dying outburst, Mr Nelsons and the orchestra were at last able to achieve the sense of reverent tranquillity that had eluded them in the more introspective passages of the earlier movements. It made for a conclusion every bit as harrowing as Mahler probably intended.
There can be little doubt that Mr Nelsons has a great affinity for Mahler and, in light of recent career developments – he recently signed a recording contract with Deutsche Grammophon, and only a few weeks ago was named the next Kapellmeister of the Gewandhaus Orchestra – it seems not unreasonable to hope for a full recorded cycle of the symphonies to emerge over the next several years. Although one has to wonder how well his performances will stand up when removed from the immediacy of the concert hall, there was enough in this evening’s reading of the Sixth to suggest a grand structural vision that will reward repeated listens.
Comentarios