Alemania
Spirit of the Moment
Over the past year, Sir Simon Rattle and the Berlin Philharmonic have given festival treatment to the symphony cycles of Schumann, Brahms and Sibelius. Rather than simply weaving the symphonies into a year’s worth of traditional concert programmes, they have performed the cycles in a single block, usually over the course of only a few days; and if the individual evenings have lacked the satisfying balance of a well-chosen programme, the chance to focus on the oeuvre of a particular composer has proven popular with audiences in Berlin and elsewhere, and has fuelled the release schedule of the orchestra’s recently-launched in-house record label.
It was only a matter of time before the orchestra turned their attention to the symphonies of Beethoven. Yet if one were compiling a list of living conductors with an affinity for that greatest of symphonists, Sir Simon might not spring to mind as an obvious choice. Most of the memorable Beethoven performances in the last few years have belonged to guest conductors – most notably Thielemann, Haitink and Fischer – and while Sir Simon has not neglected the symphonies in his own programmes, they have never seemed as essential to his core repertoire as, for instance, Mahler, Sibelius or Stravinsky.
However his recent readings of the fourth and seventh symphonies – performed with the Berlin Philharmonic as part of the first of two complete cycles given during the month of October – might have been sufficient to give the sceptics pause. Although his approach to these august works was not wholly without idiosyncrasy – and the very sound of the orchestra, lean and modern, was worlds away from the burnished grandeur achieved under Furtwängler or Karajan – the performances were committed and energetic; above all, they managed to convey the sense of an orchestra and conductor having a tremendous amount of fun doing what they do best.
Throughout the evening, the tempi chosen by Sir Simon – who conducted both works without a score – tended to be on the quick side. In the fourth symphony especially, the allegro section, which followed a perfectly-paced adagio introduction, seemed almost perilously brisk on its first appearance; the fact that the orchestra was able to achieve such a clean, detailed performance at such speeds was, itself, a source of some astonishment. Yet as the movement progressed – the welcome inclusion of the first movement repeat restored some necessary balance – the brisk pace contributed more to a sense of excitement than a suspicion that the orchestra was being merely driven too hard.
The excitability was toned down somewhat in the slow movement, which opened with an oddly-weighted lilt, but soon settled into a pace both relaxed and propulsive. Here one could grasp more fully the magnificent subtleties of which the orchestra was capable, from the awe-inspiring quiet strings at the beginning, to the delicate flute figure that introduced the movement’s beautiful closing crescendo. The scherzo that followed was unsurprisingly brisk – although offset by a pleasantly restrained trio – and the ‘ma non troppo’ of the final movement was not strictly observed; but apart from the speeds, which gave some nineteenth-century exuberance to a piece that is often played for eighteenth-century refinement, there was little evidence of intrusive interpretive decisions. Rather than trying to overthink the individual phrases or attempting to exercise dictatorial control over dynamic, Sir Simon seemed content to let the music flow.
A slightly enlarged string section for the seventh symphony – which formed the second half of the programme – gave the full orchestra a degree of extra heft but did not change the fundamentally lean, wiry quality of the sound. Even the tuttis of the first movement, which normally sound indestructible, had a delicate, almost brittle quality to them, and a cold clarity that seemed somehow at odds with the orchestra’s traditional mode of Beethoven performance.
Yet if one occasionally longed for a warmer, more enveloping tone, there remained much to admire about this seventh. The great first movement theme, propelled by flute playing of the highest order, achieved an engaging natural momentum, and the few shifts in pace and dynamic were so thoroughly integrated into the performance as to sound effortless. The second movement was even better, opening with playing of grave beauty from the basses and cellos, but soon building into something more urgent and impassioned. The chance to hear this movement performed by the Berlin Philharmonic in their own hall offered a thrill that no recording could ever truly capture.
Only in the final two movements did the furious speeds of the fourth symphony return, but once again they were upheld by playing of tremendous focus from the orchestra. The fourth movement especially achieved a hyperactive state without ever seriously suggesting that it might derail entirely; between the incisive strings, the manic precision of the timpani and the unusually animated direction of Sir Simon, the conclusion of the symphony was every bit as electrifying as one might have hoped. When it was over, the audience roared with approval and delight.
Sir Simon has recorded the cycle of Beethoven symphonies once before, with the Vienna Philharmonic, but the number of microphones and video cameras on hand for the evening’s performance would suggest that a new batch of recordings may soon be on the way. Of course what works in the concert hall isn’t always as successful in the less-forgiving context of the home stereo; but regardless of how well these performances may eventually stand up to repeated listens, it would be impossible to deny that they were thrilling in the moment.

Comentarios