Alemania
Substance and Mass
Near the very end of his life, Bach decided to assemble and rework a number of earlier compositions – supplementing them with new material – into a complete setting of the Latin mass. No one knows quite why he undertook such a project, but it proved to be oddly prescient. Less than a century later, the mass had moved out of the chapel and into the concert hall, establishing itself as a viable genre of composition that occupied the uneasy middle ground between religious devotion and secular entertainment.
Although Bach intended much of the music in his Mass in B-minor to be performed in an ecclesial setting, the scope and duration of the work as a whole is perhaps better suited to a Friday evening than a Sunday morning; yet the question of how one should appreciate the Mass is something that every conductor must address. Is it fundamentally a work of compositional ingenuity that we might enjoy in the same way as, say, a Brandenburg Concerto? Or is it closer to the Matthäus-Passion, where form and content dictate that we approach it with the kind of reverence normally reserved for a devotional experience.
Iván Fischer, in a recent performance at Berlin’s Konzerthaus chose the former, delivering a fleet, transparent reading – beautifully realised by a small ensemble of players from the Konzerthaus Orchestra and members of Vocalconsort Berlin – that managed to be unerringly musical while simultaneously downplaying the work’s essential spirituality. The piece, as Nikolaus Harnoncourt demonstrated several decades ago, is no less beautiful when shorn of romantic performance practices; yet the results on this evening, for all their technical splendour, often seemed to lack an emotional edge.
In his tenure with the Konzerthaus Orchestra, Mr Fischer has demonstrated a great affinity with the early romantic repertoire – his performances of Beethoven and Schubert, especially, have a selfless grandeur that seems to be largely out of fashion with younger conductors – and one might not have been completely surprised if he had opted for a tastefully large-scale Mass. Yet the orchestra that appeared on stage, if not quite at the minimum of period performance standards, was small enough to create an intimate sound of impressive balance and clarity.
The choir, with a mere thirty-two singers divided among the five sections, was similarly modest in scale, although the absence of overpowering force allowed one to grasp Bach’s extraordinary part writing all the more clearly. Yet neither choir nor orchestra had any problem filling the auditorium of the Konzerthaus and, indeed, it was the finely weighted balance between the two that proved to be one of the most consistently remarkable aspects of the evening. This was a performance designed not to overwhelm, but to elaborate, and in that respect it was a great success.
There were few moments where one was not aware of the music as a series of constituent parts – ornate woodwind figures, inventive bass lines and subtle flourishes from the organ – drawing inspiration from one another and coalescing into something greater; and when the instruments and the choir locked together – as they did most spectacularly in the Crucifixus section of the Credo – the cumulative effect of the whole was no less stirring for placing the diverse elements of its structure on full display.
However Mr Fischer’s pursuit of musical clarity – combined with tempi that remained consistently brisk throughout the evening – also had its drawbacks. In the almost-surprisingly quick opening Kyrie eleison there seemed to be an almost wilful absence of legato, with each note of each syllable articulated so cleanly that one began to lose sight of the drama and profundity in the words themselves. Even in the Et in terra pax section of the Gloria, slowed down to a more stately pace, there was a sense that the import of the text was of secondary importance to the elaboration of the score. One need not necessarily believe in the words for them to resonate; yet while the Cum sancto spiritu brought the Gloria to a thrilling conclusion, there were other sections, notably the closing Dona nobis pacem, that seemed oddly indifferent to the mood suggested by the text.
Yet if one longed occasionally for a reading of greater emotional involvement, the performances themselves were rarely less than distinguished. Of the five vocal soloists, Wiebke Lehmkuhl’s alto provided the evening with some of its finest moments. Her firm, elegant tone and subtle ornamentation was matched with a natural phrasing that invested her Qui sedes ad dexteram patris with great nobility and, in the Agnus Dei, managed to hint at a considerable depth of feeling beneath the façade of solemnity. Hanno Müller-Brachmann’s two Bass arias were similarly excellent. The authority of his Quoniam tu solus sanctus was enlivened by an edge of fervour and in Et in spiritum sanctum he demonstrated a great ease navigating those passages that must have sat close to the top of his range.
The choir proved exceptional throughout the evening. With such a small number there was little room for error, but the individual groups demonstrated an exacting control, and blended together into a thrillingly detailed whole. The orchestra, too, revealed few weaknesses, with especially strong performances from the two double-bassists – whose spirited playing provided so much of the evening’s momentum – as well as the pairs of flautists and oboists (who spent their evening arranged around the podium, where one might normally expect to find the first chair strings).
There is certainly enough to enjoy in the score of Bach’s Mass without paying too much attention to the meaning of the text, and Iván Fischer’s determination to sidestep the function of the piece allowed the music to shine with a clarity that was impressive on its own. Yet while his reluctance to admit any overt romantic phrasing into the Mass may have been period appropriate, there were parts of the evening where one had a sense of being kept at perhaps too respectful a distance from a work whose beauty and drama demanded closer engagement.
Comentarios