Alemania
The Big Sound
Anyone with a record player and a stack of old Deutsche Grammophon LPs will almost certainly have their own Platonic ideal of what the Berlin Philharmonic should sound like. Of course that famous sound, opulent and detailed, startlingly immediate yet completely refined, may never have existed – perhaps it was just an elaborate myth constructed by the Tonmeister and their well-placed microphones – and, in any event, there seem to be few conductors in the present day with an interest in coaxing such dated sonics from the orchestra.
Yet the Berlin Philharmonic is still very much capable of summoning something close to that mythic sound, and when it appears – which it did during a recent guest appearance from Bernard Haitink who led the orchestra in a programme of Mozart and Bruckner – it can be genuinely invigorating. In this instance, the tone was set by the majestic, imposing opening chord of Mozart’s Piano Concerto No. 25 (KV 503), which used the magnificent unity of the strings to fill the hall with weight and warmth. It may no longer be fashionable to play Mozart with such a robust sound, but few would argue that it was not deeply satisfying.
Mr Haitink may be indelibly associated with the Concertgebouw Orchestra, with whom he made his most celebrated recordings, but he has been a regular guest conductor with the Berlin Philharmonic for some fifty years, and the evidence of that long relationship was audible in the highly concentrated playing of the orchestra. As the introduction moved toward the first appearance of the piano, one heard not so much the sound of faultless precision, but of absolute assurance and total comfort; and the music that followed was as notable for its refinement as for its muscular heft.
Against the might of the orchestra, soloist Till Fellner’s playing stood out for its delicate manner. His crisp articulation never permitted the instrument to make any more sound than was absolutely necessary – even the insistent repeated notes that underscore the first section were not given undue prominence – and his playing was governed by an exacting rhythmic sensibility that stopped just short of rigidity. Only in the first movement cadenza – he used Alfred Brendel’s – did he allow himself a few tentative moments of romantic introspection; yet his performance was, for the most part free of any excesses of phrasing that might have drawn attention to themselves.
Although Mr Fellner played with great skill and sound judgment, one never felt as though he was the dominant force driving and shaping the concerto; yet Mr Haitink, for all his authority, seemed content to keep the orchestra in a supporting role, creating a well-defined space for the piano without every trying to overshadow it. But even with neither orchestra nor soloist taking a decisive lead – both parties were, perhaps, acting in deference to the score itself – there nonetheless emerged a total performance of great elegance.
The tranquil second movement, which opened with Mr Haitink conjuring subtle string eddies, maintained a stately pace while never falling into the trap of growing too relaxed; here, as elsewhere, Mr Fellner’s tightly controlled piano excursions found a foil in the exceptional, understated playing of the solo flute and solo oboe. The third movement, with its deceptively simple theme, proceeded with great energy and effortless momentum, building to a conclusion that used the full weight of the orchestra to suggest a great nobility of spirit.
The impressive sound that Mr Haitink and the orchestra were able to achieve during the Mozart augured well for the programme’s second half, which featured Bruckner’s Ninth Symphony; and things did indeed get off to a promising start, with an introduction from the strings that achieved something close to the reverent pianissimo noted in the score, followed by a solemn announcement from the assembled horns. Yet it soon became apparent that Mr Haitink was interested neither in extremes of dynamic nor in trying to invest the work with the kind of last-word profundity that so often accompanies Bruckner’s unfinished final symphony. This is not to say that he sped through the first movement with no attention to detail – indeed, his tempi were consistently on the solemn side – nor did he lack an innate feel for the larger structure; the movement’s different episodes, which can seem disjointed in the hands of some conductors, fit together like perfectly laid slabs of marble.
There was plenty of beauty to be found – notably the gorgeously-played theme introduced by the strings after the first tutti dies away – and, in the first movement finale, some terror as well; but alongside that was a certain quiet inflexibility, an unwillingness to draw out certain phrases for the sake of heightening their emotional force, or to magnify the distance between the near imperceptible and the almost overwhelming. These are not points for which one might normally fault a conductor, yet the greatest Bruckner performances find a way of punctuating their restraint with a few well-chosen moments of calculated abandon. On this evening, the first movement, while never over-mannered and frequently exciting, had a matter-of-fact quality that occasionally precluded a clear view of Bruckner’s own visions of the beyond.
The scherzo of the second movement opened with a furious pizzicato that was soon overtaken by one of Bruckner’s most apocalyptic utterances, played here with great severity; one could not help but be impressed by the strikingly vast sound achieved by the orchestra, and yet the metrical quality of the rhythm seemed a shade too controlled. The trio, driven by an insistent single-note pulse from the basses, flowed with greater ease but sounded no more comforting.
Only in the concluding Adagio was there a sense that the tight control which had governed the first two movements was starting to dissipate; some of the slowest parts seemed to lack focus, and the passage preceding the movement’s terrifying climax wasn’t quite able to summon the inexorable momentum it required. There was, however, exceptional playing from all sections of the orchestra, perhaps most notably the Wagner tubas who managed the rare feat (normally only heard in studio recordings) of holding their longest sustained chords with almost no hint of wobble.
Even if one did not agree with all of Mr Haitink’s interpretive decisions, his feel for the architecture of the symphony and his willingness to draw a big sound from the Berlin Philharmonic resulted in many moments that were undeniably impressive. However it was ultimately the Mozart – delivered with a near-perfect balance of classical grace and full-band warmth – that would hold the evening’s greatest rewards.
Comentarios