Discos
Struggles and triumphs
The popularity of Sibelius in the twentieth century was, to some extent, tied to the rise of commercially available sound recordings. Although he had already stopped writing new music by the 1930s, his symphonies in particular were championed by a number of conductors – Kajanus, Beecham and Koussevitzky – who also happened to be pioneers of the recording studio. In the decades since those earliest recordings, the symphonies have never suffered from a lack of availability; yet the highest peaks in the catalogue – Karajan (who never recorded the Third symphony), Barbirolli and, more recently, Neeme Järvi – sit only slightly above a diverse array of other worthy interpretations that, taken together, offer a reasonably consistent picture of Sibelius the symphonist.
But for those who would question the need for yet another Sibelius cycle in the marketplace, it may come as something of a surprise to discover that the version of the Fourth symphony which appears on the new box from Berlin Philharmonic’s in-house record label is quite possibly one of the finest ever recorded. The recording is live – all of the symphonies on the set were taped at a series of concerts given by the orchestra under Sir Simon Rattle at the Philharmonie in February of 2015 – but what we hear on the CD is evidence of a once-in-a-lifetime performance, thirty-eight minutes of something closer to alchemy than mere synergy.
The only other recording of the Fourth that comes anywhere close was, incidentally, made by the same orchestra some fifty years earlier under the baton of Herbert von Karajan. But where Karajan strives for profundity, Sir Simon achieves an elemental grandeur from the very outset. The opening cluster of strings soon settle into a tidal motion from which the arrestingly beautiful solo cello emerges like a faint glow in the darkness. Before long one hears the horns and trumpets, distant and burnished; they will soon grow more forceful, but never in such a way as to upset the balance. The first movement moves forward not according to the rules that govern normal symphonies, but according to a pace that is almost geological.
The appearance of the brisk dance-like motif at the opening of the second movement does little to dispel the alien mood established in the first, and the slow prismatic swells of the third movement are underscored by an immense tension. In the fourth movement, which all too often seems to fade away, Sir Simon’s reading is able to hint at the fierce internal struggle that lies just beneath the gloomy surface of the score, a struggle for which there is no obvious resolution. Throughout the length of the symphony, the orchestra seems possessed by an almost terrifying sense of purpose; from the sombre unity of the horns, to the dark intrusions of the basses, to the forlorn oboes, there is not a section that does not turn in a performance of the highest calibre.
There may be no grand revelations in this performance, no passages that will cause anyone who knows the symphony to view it in a substantially different way. But neither are there any obvious flaws to break the spell. For the duration of the work, one ceases to be aware of the fact that this extraordinary music was, at some point, brought into being by real musicians, playing real instruments inside a real concert hall; one hears only the music itself.
It would be unreasonable to expect the rest of the set to live up to such a highly charged moment of inspiration and, while the remaining six symphonies are given strong performances, there is nothing else that stands as definitive. The Fifth – arguably the towering masterpiece within Sibelius’ oeuvre – is given a fine performance that nonetheless sounds a touch mannered in several places, notably the build-up to the Allegro section of the first movement and the introduction of the celebrated brass figure that dominates the finale. The inner sections of the Seventh symphony, on the other hand, sound so meticulously controlled that they are rarely given adequate space to breath. Here, more than anywhere else in the cycle, one becomes aware of a conductor pulling the strings, making minor adjustments in dynamic and tempo that prove more distracting than invigorating.
However the two early symphonies are given thoroughly engaging performances; the First, especially, is arguably an improvement on Sir Simon’s earlier Birmingham recording, with the work’s folkloric tendencies pushed back to make room for the kind of natural drama that Sibelius would develop in his subsequent symphonies. The Second symphony, despite a few laboured moments in the final movement, is also given a winning performance, with the sunny sway of the opening giving way to a majestically-paced slow movement full of quiet struggles and intense exclamations. Even the slight Third symphony and oft-neglected Sixth are given noble, refined performances that suggest a high level of commitment and preparation.
Perhaps the biggest criticism of this box is that the disposition of the seven symphonies over the four discs is somewhat awkward, with the thirty-three minute Fifth symphony ending up alone on a single disc. Presumably contractual issues prevented the release of the Violin Concerto that was performed during the same concert series, but surely the orchestra could have whipped up a quick Tapiola to fill the third disc to a respectable length.
As with the previous releases on Berliner Philharmoniker Recordings, all of the live tapes have been well edited, and the inevitable coughing and shuffling of the audience has been rendered virtually inaudible; the process of removing the background noise does, alas, come at the expense of some of the high-end sparkle that one might find in a studio recording, but this ultimately does nothing to diminish one’s enjoyment of the performances themselves. The packaging, of course, is very much up to the standards that we have come to expect from the label, with the four CDs and two Blu-Ray discs and an extensive booklet bound together into one of their trademark long boxes. While it is nice to have video of the concert performances on the second Blu-Ray disc – the first contains uncompressed audio – the concerts themselves can not ultimately reveal the mystery of what happened at the Philharmonie on that February night to make the Fourth symphony so magnificent.
Comentarios