Alemania

Life and afterlife

Jesse Simon
Life and afterlife
Berlin, domingo, 10 de enero de 2016.
Philharmonie. Chausson: Poème de l'amour et de la mer, op. 19. Debussy: Dances for harp and strings. Fauré: Requiem, op. 48. Sophie Koch, mezzo-soprano. Marie-Pierre Langlamet, harp. Christiane Karg, soprano. Adrian Eröd, baritone. Rundfunkchor Berlin. Berlin Philharmonic. Christian Thielemann, conductor
0,0001832

Christian Thielemann’s annual guest appearances with the Berlin Philharmonic have established themselves as a consistent highlight in the otherwise unpromising depths of winter. His assurance within the pantheon of Central European heavy-hitters - notably Brahms, Bruckner and Strauss - and his ability to draw playing of heightened focus from the orchestra have resulted in numerous memorable evenings at the Philharmonie. Yet for his most recent visit, Mr Thielemann moved away from the geographic heart of the European continent - although not from his late-romantic comfort zone - for a programme of three very different French pieces, all composed within the span of some twenty years around the turn of the previous century.

If the programme was intriguing in print, it ended up being somewhat perplexing in reality. Both Debussy's relatively minor Danses for harp and strings and Chausson’s less-frequently performed Poème de l’amour et de la mer - which appeared on this evening as the missing link between Wagner’s chromaticism and Debussy’s luminous drift - were given strong, frequently engaging performances, yet both seemed curiously insubstantial when weighed against a reading of Fauré’s much-loved Requiem that seemed intent on trading the work’s quiet mysticism for a joyless severity.

Chausson’s Poème, a setting of texts by Maurice Bouchor for mezzo-soprano and orchestra, is a work of brilliant moments that never quite add up to a transcendent whole. Its inspirations are obvious and its influence even more so: Chausson’s often magical orchestral passages all but challenge future composers to come up with a more vivid evocation of the sea. (Debussy, a friend and admirer of Chausson, would later accept this unstated challenge).

Mr Thielemann’s reading of the Poème featured perhaps the most extraordinary playing that would emerge from the orchestra on this evening, with the grand, ethereal strings contributing to a magnificent full-orchestra sound. Unlike the later Requiem, the Poème also suggested a much greater freedom of movement; even at its most rapturous, the piece sounded almost wholly free of directorial manipulation. The fragmented melody that appeared at the end of the first section, especially, had the sense of cresting and falling in a manner that seemed wholly organic; and in the third section, Mr Thielemann, drawing perhaps on his opera house expertise, was able to elevate the climax to a suitably agonised level before allowing the sound to drain slowly away during the gloomy coda.

Although the texts often seemed like a loose agglomeration of not-unfamiliar romantic imagery, Sophie Koch, wearing an expression of troubled wistfulness throughout the duration of the piece, delivered them with convincing solemnity. Her most emphatic moments were never piercing, and the quiet ruminations that made up the bulk of the piece managed to stay afloat on the proto-impressionist seas conjured by the orchestra. Yet despite what was undoubtedly a fine performance from all involved, the catharsis promised (or at least suggested) by the opening movement never quite arrived.

Debussy’s Danses for harp and string orchestra may not be in the same league as Images or La Mer, but its concise good humour and satisfying internal logic offered a pleasing contrast to the sprawling Poème. The opening ‘Danse sacrée’ had a sombre, nocturnal quality that was not especially dance-like, but in the ‘Danse profane’, the strings locked into an agreeable sway that suggested a kind of distant narcotic waltz. The light touch and effortless virtuosity of Marie-Pierre Langlamet - also the principal harpist of the Berlin Philharmonic - made for a thoroughly engaging performance of an undemandingly delightful work.

After the graceful lilt of the Debussy and the romantic lustre of the Chausson, the opening of Fauré’s Requiem was startling for its extreme austerity. The Requiem may, in its conception and subject matter, be a far graver work than either of the preceding two, but its greatness rests primarily in the gentle lyricism that permits occasional glimpses of the text’s eternal light. However Mr Thielemann’s approach left little room for anything other than pure solemnity.

The balance of sound remained an issue throughout the performance. In the introductory ‘Requiem aeternam’ section, the choir was dominant, reducing the soft bed of the strings and the subtle accents of the horns to a marginal role; and in the Sanctus, an impressive build to the climactic ‘Hosanna’ was undermined by the muscle of the organ. Indeed, the organ was problematic more often than not; while one might have wished for a greater sense of legato in certain passages, it was the instrument itself that proved most distracting, obscuring the orchestra in what should have been a mighty climax to the Agnus Dei, and crushing the strings with an unheavenly toot during the opening bars of In Paradisum.

Despite these shortcomings, there were also numerous moments in which the exceptional force of Fauré’s vision was given due illumination. Mr Thielemann was able to mould the opening melody of the Agnus Dei into an utterance of earthly beauty, before slowing down the same movement’s ‘Lux aeterna’ section to a reverence pace in preparation for the great crescendo. In both this movement, and in the ‘Dies illa’ section of the following Libera me, the choir and orchestra seemed at last to have reached something close to an ideal balance.

Adrian Eröd’s bright tone was well suited to the ‘Hostias’ section of the Offertoire, although his urbane phrasing - notably in the dramatic Libera me - sometimes suggested a Liederabend more than an unguarded moment of spiritual devotion. The Pie Jesu, however, found its perfect expression in the voice of Christiane Karg. Indeed, Ms Karg’s performance - the purity and clarity of her voice had just enough subtle shading to give the words an intriguing depth - seemed to inspire Mr Thielemann and the orchestra to a level of nobility far surpassing anything that had emerged from the stage on this evening.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.