Alemania

Momentary weightlessness

Jesse Simon
Olivier Messiaen
Olivier Messiaen © Rob C. Croes | Anefo - Nationaal Archief, CC0,
Berlin, sábado, 27 de febrero de 2016.
Konzerthaus Berlin. Messiaen: Turangalîla-Symphonie. Roger Muraro, piano. Valérie Hartmann-Claverie, ondes Martenot. Konzerthaus Orchestra. Iván Fischer, conductor
7,84E-05

The ingredients for a successful performance of Messiaen’s Turangalîla-Symphonie are numerous; not only does one require a large, well-rehearsed orchestra with an arsenal of percussionists, but a virtuoso pianist who can integrate themselves into the orchestra, and someone who knows their way around an ondes Martenot. Despite (or perhaps because of) its great technical requirements, the piece has spent the two decades since Messiaen’s death inching its way from the periphery of the repertoire to the core, and attracting new followers with every performance.

Yet the mounting popularity of this monumental work is not wholly surprising. For all its conceptual underpinnings and ingenious treatments of rhythm and texture, the appeal of the symphony rests largely in its direct expressions of ecstasy – a kind of secular spirituality, temporarily untethered from the overt Catholicism that would inspire Messiaen’s greatest solo organ compositions – and a recent performance at Berlin’s Konzerthaus conducted by Iván Fischer demonstrated the work’s continued ability to establish an immediate and intimate line of communication with its audience.

Messiaen had fairly strict ideas regarding the tempi of his own pieces, and the pacing of the different movements on this evening remained reasonably consistent with those found on the recordings supervised by the composer himself; if anything Mr Fischer tended toward slowness and restraint, resisting the temptation to use speed as a means of keeping the disparate sections of a given movement together. If this approach resulted in a handful of passages which drew unwanted attention to the seams of the piece – the second movement especially contained one or two jarring transitions – it led more often to moments of heightened force and beauty. The hypnotic pace of the sixth movement, languid but never lazy, sustained an unbroken mood of reverie for nearly a quarter hour.

Indeed Mr Fischer’s command of the orchestra remained impressive throughout. In the fourth movement and especially in the thematic developments of the eighth movement, he was able to create a sense that each crescendo was somehow bigger than the last, challenging the orchestra to outdo itself in terms of grandeur and generally succeeding; and his control of rhythm was nowhere more evident than in the fifth movement, which started a touch rigid but soon found a measure of freedom within its unstoppable momentum.

Yet Mr Fischer’s greatest strength may have been his ability not to impose too much order on the symphony’s wildest sections. In almost every movement (but especially in the second, fifth and seventh) there came a passage where the different forces within the orchestra started to work against one another so furiously that they created the illusion of a precarious stasis. Where some conductors might try to move through these passages as quickly as possible or align them to some kind of fixed pulse, Mr Fischer seemed to delight in the disorienting suspension, allowing the entire symphony to achieve momentary weightlessness before resolving again into something more rhythmically focussed.

The Konzerthaus orchestra had little problem with the demands of the score, sliding constantly between the work’s two poles of overwhelming magnitude and sublime tenderness. One might easily single out the strings for their glassy fragility in the sixth movement, the consistently elegant playing of the clarinets, the tireless percussion section who found a guiding logic in the difficult cross-rhythms of the seventh movement or, especially, the three trombones whose multiple iterations of the ‘statue’ theme displayed arresting levels of discipline. Yet it was the sound of the full orchestra – often forceful, but rarely at the expense of detail – that remained most arresting. Only the final movement suffered from a lack of clarity as competing blocks of rhythm and sound refused to make way for one another.

Roger Muraro has a long-standing relationship with Messiaen’s music and has performed and recorded the Turangalîla’s solo-piano part numerous times over the past quarter century; yet one was not always convinced that his approach was ideally matched to Mr Fischer’s. The piano was surprisingly high in the sonic balance, to the point where the rapidly alternating notes that colour the first appearances of the ‘statue’ theme drew attention away from the trombones. But even beyond volume, many of the unaccompanied passages displayed a tendency to pull against Mr Fischer’s deliberate speeds, breaking into a gallop before collapsing into a chaos of notes. The solo-piano part does indeed have its chaotic moments, but on this evening they did not seem wholly mitigated by corresponding expressions of lucidity.

If one occasionally longed for greater restraint in the piano, there were few such misgivings about Valérie Hartmann-Claverie’s performance on the ondes Martenot. Ms Hartmann-Claverie, who studied with Jeanne Loriod and, like Mr Muraro, has a long association with the symphony, was able to hide among the strings of the sixth movement, adding depth and colour to their celestial glissandi, but was equally adept at bringing the instrument’s inherent otherness to the fore at crucial moments.

The end of the piece, a radiant chord held by the full orchestra, was greeted not only by the customary applause of the audience but by a few whoops and cheers as well. Such reactions are not uncommon. Messiaen made no secret of his attempts to use the volume and intensity of sound as a means of recreating – or at least suggesting – a kind of spiritual transcendence. At the end of a well-directed and well-played performance, it is only natural that one might have trouble containing their enthusiasm.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.