Alemania
Perpetual Agitation
The Vienna Philharmonic have been frequent guests at the Staatsoper’s annual Festtage, and in the past three years they have performed final symphonies by composers especially associated with the musical life of the Austrian capital: last year it was Schubert’s Great C-major symphony, and the year before featured the final three of Mozart. For their appearance this year, Daniel Barenboim guided the Vienna players through a consistently intriguing performance of Mahler’s final completed symphony that played to the strengths of the orchestra while, at the same time, bringing to the surface aspects of the score that often remain hidden.
It is perhaps inevitable that conductors would want to smooth over the difficult passages, the odd transitions and moments of unconventional orchestration in Mahler’s Ninth. Mr Barenboim, on the other hand, seemed to delight in the tensions that arose from playing them straight. His vision of the symphony seemed to argue that, beneath the beautiful late-romantic surfaces lay a fairly prominent strain of proto-modernism; even in his most valedictory work, Mahler had his eye on the future.
At the heart of Mr Barenboim’s reading was a deep volatility. Anyone used to hearing the opening movement performed with a presiding sense of reverential mysticism might have found themselves disoriented by the back and forth pull of the music and the slightly uneasy rhythms that led up to the first outburst of the full orchestra. The episodes that followed, even the ostensibly placid passage for solo-flute near the end, seemed somehow unsettled, and the accumulation of these moments resulted in a first movement notable for its perpetual agitation. Yet if Mr Barenboim’s approach was unorthodox the results were never less than compelling.
It was a risky approach to be sure, and it might not have worked had it been performed by a less disciplined orchestra. However the unpredictable course of Mr Barenboim’s reading was matched at every turn by playing from the Vienna Philharmonic of uncompromising determination, and often breathtaking sound. The first appearance of the second violins in the opening bars served as announcement of what was to follow: the sound was silvery, the phrasing eloquent and the clarity remarkable.
Each section of the orchestra was similarly incisive, playing with an economy that allowed no sound to be wasted. The ominous trombones and the muted tuba made their point and then fell silent; a crystalline passage for cellos illuminated a crucial quiet moment, then disappeared just as quickly; even the mighty cymbal crashes and the sounding of the triangle decayed almost immediately into silence. The precision of the sound – free of everything that was not essential – was one of the evening’s most striking qualities, and a source of near constant amazement.
If the opening movement had offered nearly half an hour of dramatic tension, the endearing second movement came as something of a reprieve. Mr Barenboim’s unhurried tempo emphasised the slight drag in the Ländler, although the pace became tighter as the movement grew more rambunctious. There was even a touch of calculated coarseness in the waltz sections as the full strings declaimed an exaggerated rhythm and the caffeinated woodwinds struggled to contain their overabundance of enthusiasm.
The third movement, however, was curious for its lack of abandon. The opening was almost too insistently metrical, laying bare a pulse that seemed fated never to be swept up in the surrounding madness. Although the phrasing soon grew more fluid and the final bars were undeniably energetic, the movement seemed too tightly controlled to allow for even the illusion of spontaneity. The quiet interlude, however, featured a glassy violin sound that promised good things for the movement to come.
Indeed the violins in particular, and the strings in general were essential to the success of the final movement, which eschewed the death-haunted mysticism found in many readings in favour of something decidedly more earthbound. As with the opening movement, the symphony’s extensive finale was rendered less as a meditation than a struggle, and it was above all the strings who made the sudden and extreme shifts in dynamic – from overwhelming fullness to almost complete silence – seem not merely logical but essential.
Many a conductor has been confounded by the pressures of having to put their own interpretive stamp on a well-known, well-loved work, but this did not appear to be the case for Daniel Barenboim, whose reading on this evening was never excessive in its liberties, but also managed to approach the symphony in a manner that was undeniably different from the majority of interpretations. However it was the unerring perfection of sound provided by the Vienna Philharmonic that made Mr Barenboim’s arguments for the symphony so convincing.
Comentarios