Discos

Sounds and Visions

Jesse Simon
Beethoven: Symphonies 1–9. Berlin Philharmonic. Sir Simon Rattle. Berliner Philharmoniker Recordings. 5 CD / 3 Blu-Ray. BPHR160091
0,0001156

Beethoven’s symphonies are immediately recognisable as the work of a single composer, yet no two are alike. Each has its particular trajectory, its unique emotional gamut, its subtle nods to tradition and its less-subtle attempts to upend, expand and redefine the symphonic form; each one, on its own, has the capacity to bring immense pleasure to the casual listener, while also standing up to the highest scrutiny. Yet for those entrusted with the task of packaging and marketing the music, the arbitrary superstructure of the corpus – the idea that the nine symphonies somehow form an indivisible whole – has proved consistently popular. Since the beginning of the LP era, it has been the norm for conductors to record the full cycle, often with the same orchestra; many have felt compelled to record it more than once.

In October of 2015, Sir Simon Rattle and the Berlin Philharmonic gave two complete performances of the cycle at the Philharmonie, and the recordings from those evenings have now been made available as a deluxe box from the orchestra’s in-house label. In addition to five CDs, corresponding to the programmes of the five evenings (minus, sadly, the Leonore No. 1 overture which filled second evening to acceptable concert length), the box contains three Blu-Ray discs containing video performances of the symphonies, a documentary, a video introduction, and uncompressed audio files for the audiophiles; the attractive booklet contains notes on the symphonies plus an intriguing essay from Jonathan Del Mar on the edition used for the recordings. As an artefact, the set is assuredly up to the high standard of the label’s other releases.

Yet if the box asks us to consider the symphonies as an inseparable corpus, the recordings force us to consider each performance on its individual merits. Sir Simon, here making his second survey of the cycle – the first, with the Vienna Philharmonic from 2002, was also taken from a series of live performances – has a reasonably consistent idea of how Beethoven should sound, but the results he achieves from piece to piece are often surprisingly different. The Sixth, given a warm, often majestic reading, stands up to home listening while also suggesting some of the excitement that might have accompanied the actual performance; however it is difficult to imagine the overly-mannered Fifth being anyone’s first pick from the CD shelf.

Sir Simon, for the most part, favours a lean, compartmentalised orchestra in which the individual instrumental groups remain audible and discreet. Rather than a single entity moving forward, one is conscious of the orchestra as a highly synchronised assemblage of moving parts; one’s appreciation of this set will depend to a large extent on the degree to which they want to have those moving parts – and, by extension, the clever mechanics of Beethoven’s scores – pointed out to them. As approaches go, it is quite far removed from both the muscular wall of sound achieved by Karajan at his most lustrous or the exacting formal balance of Abbado – Sir Simon’s two immediate predecessors at the Berlin Philharmonic – but it is also not without its charms. If one sometimes misses the burnished Beethoven tutti favoured by conductors of the mid-twentieth century, one perhaps emerges with a greater appreciation of the pains which Beethoven took to make his symphonies sound effortless.

Sir Simon’s ability to generate momentum within a given movement is perhaps his greatest asset as a Beethoven conductor, and the most exciting parts of this cycle – the Allegro section in the first movement of the Fourth, or the spirited Finale of the Seventh – feel as though he has set the symphony rolling down a steep incline, and is controlling the orchestra more by reining them in than by driving them forward. His ability to locate and highlight rhythmic elements often works to the benefit of the shower movements: the beautifully played Adagio of the Fourth is spacious but never meandering, and the Szene am Bach of the Sixth moves forward with subtle animation.Yet his tendency toward brisk tempi in the outer movements can just as easily result in moments that seem strangely uninvolving: the final movement of the Fifth manages the extraordinary task of sounding un-monumental, while the mighty descending figure that coalesces in the opening bars of the Ninth – one of the most urgent, impassioned passages in any of the nine symphonies – comes across as cursory.

A more troubling tendency, which surfaces throughout the cycle, is Sir Simon’s willingness to over-emphasise a moment or over-sculpt a particular phrase. There are moments when it works: the subtly exaggerated rhythm of the Seventh’s second movement imparts a funereal inevitability even more compelling than its corresponding movement in the Third. The slow movement of the Fifth, however, is so full of tiny adjustments in tempo and dynamic that the perpetual busyness interferes with the flow of the music. Beethoven’s symphonies are, to be fair, among the most recorded works of the past seventy years and the task of bringing something new to the table can be daunting. Yet in the least satisfying moments of this cycle, one can almost hear the strain that arises when the reading pushes too heavily against the defensible limitations of the score. If there is ultimately nothing out of place, there are perhaps a few too many passages in which the interpretive choices are more distracting than revealing.

Still, the box will undoubtedly be a welcome souvenir for anyone who attended the Berlin concerts, or who had the opportunity to see the cycle on tour in Vienna, Paris, New York or Tokyo … but it also represents something of a missed opportunity. When Rafael Kubelik set out to record his (still somewhat underrated) cycle in the 1970s, he chose a different orchestra for each symphony, hoping to shake off some of the homogeneity that might have arisen had he recorded the whole thing in Munich. It is intriguing to imagine what might have happened if, contra Kubelik’s model, it was the orchestra and not the conductor which had acted as sole constant.

During the past five years, the Berlin Philharmonic have been responsible for some extraordinary Beethoven performances, but many have come from conductors who, freed from the pressures of a full cycle, have been able to offer extesnive insights into a particular symphony: that list includes Paavo Järvi (the First), Christian Thielemann (the Third), Gustavo Dudamel (the Fourth), the late Nikolaus Harnoncourt (the Fifth), Bernard Haitink (the Sixth), and even Sir Simon himself (a highly charged Seventh from 2012). A cycle in which the conductor changed from symphony to symphony might have stood as a more fitting tribute to an orchestra whose unquestioned strength of musicianship is matched by an ability to adapt their sound to different visions.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.