Estados Unidos
The Best of Both Worlds
The task of locating the precise balance between erudition and passion in Capriccio is one of the great challenges facing any prospective director: even the slightest misjudgement can result in a staging that comes across as overly mannered or, worse, that finds itself guilty of the very triviality to which the Countess alludes in her final moments on stage. It is thus no faint praise to say that the greatest strength of Tim Albery’s understated new production of Strauss’ final opera – performed as part of the Santa Fe Opera’s sixtieth season – was its restraint. Mr Albery did not attempt to overplay the comedy or italicise the opera’s various aesthetic arguments; rather, he employed a tasteful setting and fully realised characters as a means of articulating and enhancing the wealth of ideas found in the libretto. The resulting drama was both intellectually rewarding and thoroughly entertaining.
Although it is the grand struggle between words and music, personified in the rivalry of Olivier and Flamand, which provides Capriccio with its most obvious opposition, Mr Albery’s production was full of similar binaries: the ostentatious Clairon, with her grand entrance, was established as a foil for the pure artistic spirit of the Countess, while the dreamy demeanour of the Count served to highlight the eternal pragmatism of La Roche. Even the elegant set – which featured a small neo-classical salon with gilded pilasters and arched windows surrounded by the steel frame and plate-glass of a modernist villa – contributed to the production’s gallery of contrasts. During the entertainments of the ninth scene, a group of three Louis XV chairs and three Breuer-style tubular-frame chairs became intermingled as the characters moved from one part of the salon to another.
For all the thought that had clearly gone into the elaborate system of opposing ideas, the production wore its conceptual framework lightly. The contrasts were there for anyone who wished to find them, but they rarely drew attention to their own cleverness. And while Mr Albery seemed especially attuned to the opera’s undercurrents of cynicism, irony and parody, they were never allowed to overwhelm the drama, which remained driven largely by the conflicting desires of the characters. Yet even those desires were treated with a light touch, leavening the constant aesthetic disagreements with a necessary dose of low-key humour.
The production, for all its strengths, might not have been as successful without its strong – and surprisingly selfless – ensemble cast. None of the singers went out of their way to steal the spotlight, but each of the six principal characters were vivid and memorable, and the chemistry that existed between them contributed to the production’s lively pace and affable mood. If Olivier and Flamand were somewhat hapless as suitors, their relationships with one another – and with La Roche, their benefactor and tormentor – were fully credible, and the two longer exchanges between the Count and Countess (scenes two and eight) were especially notable for their natural charm. Even the two part octet at the centre of the opera maintained a coherent shape despite its overlapping dialogue and mounting complexities.
Vocally the performances were consistently solid, with frequent moments of inspiration. The light-toned Flamand of Ben Bliss was unerringly melodic and largely convincing in his passions for the Countess. Only occasionally did one long for a tenor with greater tonal heft and a slightly more heroic edge; his pleas of ‘Entscheidet, entscheidet,’ especially, called for greater resolve. Joshua Hopkins, however, was a strong Olivier; he seemed less invested in the Countess than in his craft, and his articulate, slightly detached delivery suggested a pronounced awareness of the absurdity of his own situation. The way he widened his eyes slightly at the mention of Metastasio was comedic understatement at its finest, yet at various moments – most notably during his brief exchange with Clairon – one was able to glimpse the genuine passions behind the calm facade.
As the mediating force between art and commerce, La Roche was given a sturdy, engaging performance from David Govertsen who delivered his lines with requisite authority. The scenes with Olivier and Flamand were enlivened by his haughty manner – this was a La Roche who clearly believed he was doing his composer and dramatist a favour – and his exaggeratedly lofty tone positioned his grand monologue as the pompous flipside to the sincerity of the Countess’ final scene. Although the Count of Craig Verm had comparatively little stage time and a tendency to remain on the sidelines during the large ensemble scenes, his two sparkling scenes with the Countess possessed great vocal charisma, and his earnest pursuit of Clairon suggested an almost surprising nobility of purpose.
Susan Graham was an equally fine Clairon, with a generous, slightly steely voice that suited the character well; although she was never less than charming, she maintained a subtle aloofness in her dealings with La Roche, the Countess and, especially, the Count. If her brief passage of spoken dialogue wasn’t wholly convincing, her world-weary manner offered a necessary counter-balance to the Count’s mercurial ardour. As the Countess, Amanda Majeski seemed unwilling to engage fully with the attentions of Olivier and Flamand and, in doing so, expressed a welcome ambivalence regarding her position as both the heart and conclusion of the opera; yet the cool tone she adopted while attempting to keep her suitors at arm’s length dissolved completely in her dialogues with the Count. She seemed a touch mannered when repeating the sonnet at the opening of the final scene, but grew more natural (and more compelling) when given the chance to bring the volatility of her passions to the fore.
Throughout the evening, conductor Leo Hussain seemed more attuned to the opera’s neoclassical elements than its moments of Straussian drama. There were a few key scenes – notably La Roche’s monologue, and the exchange between Flamand and the Countess – in which the music was unable to heighten the emotions of the moment, and for much of the final scene, the orchestra sounded measured and unbalanced where it should have been luminous. Most of the evening, however, was delightful. At his most attentive, Mr Hussain was able to maintain a natural flow of drama while highlighting the playful details in Strauss’ score; when La Roche complained about the music overwhelming the singers, the orchestra grew appropriately loud. The playing – especially in the ninth scene where the gentle dances alternated with larger orchestral forces – was of a consistently high quality.
If Strauss’ early operas aim for catharsis, Capriccio seems content to arrive at formal balance. In maintaining a reverence for this balance, Mr Albery’s staging was perhaps overly safe; certainly the production made few attempts to recontextualise or revise the basic story. Yet its ability to fuse the work’s emotional and intellectual strands into an inseparable whole – and to draw the audience almost effortlessly into its arguments – was both satisfying at a dramatic level, and wholly consistent with opera’s designation as a ‘conversation piece’. Long after the music and applause had ended, the audience was left much to talk – and think – about.



Comentarios