Alemania

Musikfest 2: Chemists, Alchemists and Dark Stars

Jesse Simon
---
---
Berlin, viernes, 9 de septiembre de 2016.
Philharmonie. Debussy: Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune. Varèse: Arcana. Berlioz: Symphonie fantastique, op. 14. Berlin Philharmonic. Andris Nelsons, conductor
0,0001454

This was one of those quietly satisfying evenings on which the difficult process of making great music sound great seemed like the most natural thing in the world. Andris Nelsons, returning to Musikfest Berlin after last year’s memorably volatile performance of Mahler’s Sixth with the Boston Symphony orchestra, led the Berlin Philharmonic through a programme of works by three composers – Debussy, Varèse and Berlioz – known for their highly individual approaches to orchestration. Mr Nelsons has always had a strong rapport with this orchestra, but on this evening the two conspired to create diverse worlds of sound as magical as they were effortless.

The Berlin Philharmonic may have one of the better string sections in the world, but they don’t always sound as grand as they did on this evening. Although their finest moments would occur in the second half, the exceptionally lustrous sound was apparent even in the opening of the first piece, Debussy’s Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune. After the introductory flute passage – slow, quiet and mesmerising – the violas and cellos emerged with a rapt, translucent tremolando to which the first violins added, somewhat surprisingly, a touch of darkness.

The Prélude is a fragile work in so far as its spell can be broken easily by an overzealous crescendo or an ill-judged shift of tempo. Yet Andris Nelsons, whose readings often employ a kind of wilful edginess as a means of generating excitement, approached the work with a selflessness that bordered on invisibility. Apart from setting a deliberately slow pace, which was maintained for the duration of the piece, one was never aware of his attempts to pull or shape the music. Debussy’s score unfolded with organic grace, it’s captivating mood intact from beginning to end.

If the works of Debussy opened up new harmonic and textural possibilities for orchestral music in the twentieth century, the two large-scale works composed by Varèse in the 1920s – Arcana, and the earlier Amériques – represent something of a terminal point; they stand as imposing monoliths marking a point beyond which it is possible to go no further. In Arcana, especially, there is a sense of self-conscious excess: while it lasts only twenty minutes, it presents itself as a large work that delights in its own vast dimensions, and a loud work determined to explore all of the different ways in which it can be overwhelming.

Although one can hear echoes of Stravinsky in some of Varèse’s textures, there is nothing remotely balletic about Arcana; indeed, at times is seems to possess a heaviness that, in a less taut performance, could be mistaken for clumsiness. Mr Nelsons made no attempts to downplay the scale of Varèse’s conception, but the extreme discipline of his reading and the faultless precision of the orchestra imparted a vitality to the performance which offset the work’s lumbering cosmic assault. The sudden eruptions from the percussion section – which numbered thirteen players in addition to a timpanist – came across as controlled explosions, and the imposing full orchestra passages were notable not just for their extremes of volume, but also their complete lack of rough edges.

The composure offered by both orchestra and conductor worked ultimately to the advantage of the piece. Arcana contains enough excitement in its colossal score that the most engaging performance will be shaped more by restraint than exaggeration. The sounds that emerged from the orchestra were titanic, to be sure, but also exactingly crafted and remarkably well-ordered. When the piece was over – concluding with an icy fade from the high strings – one felt more invigorated than dazed.

Just as audiences of the 1920s may have been perplexed and shocked by the fearsome sounds created by Varèse, so too did audiences of the 1830s initially find themselves perturbed by the chemically-induced fever-dreams of Berlioz’s Symphonie fantastique. Although the piece, which has long been a staple of the standard repertoire, can sound tame to modern audiences – especially when preceded by a work on the scale of Arcana – the performance on this evening was extravagant, entertaining and, for a few moments in the final movement, convincingly demonic.

The success of the evening’s performance was due in equal parts to the interpretation of Mr Nelsons, who never lost sight of the idea that the five movements were part of a larger narrative arc, and the magnificent sound of an orchestra fully in their element. The strings, especially, were a source of constant amazement: when playing together they achieved a sound of extraordinary opulence, but one in which the contributions of each group remained audibly discrete. Although their rich, graceful tone very much propelled the opening movement – which sounded a touch mannered at the outset but grew more natural as the reveries blossomed into passions – their sound was nowhere more majestic than in the second movement: the luxurious waltz, played with no lack of vigour, built to a whirling finale that even the later Viennese practitioners could not have surpassed.

The strings, of course, were far from the orchestra’s only asset. The third movement opened with an exceptionally played dialogue between oboe and cor anglais, and ended with sensitive surround-sound timpani performed by musicians situated just outside the side-exits of the auditorium; and the first appearance of the witches sabbath theme on the solo clarinet was played with total animation, great fluidity and a delightful edge of the macabre. Yet it was Mr Nelsons who was able to weave these disparate elements into a compelling whole. He was committed to the essential romanticism of the first two movements and the pastoral mood of the third, but unafraid to draw out the heroism of the fourth or the grotesqueries of the fifth. The march to the scaffold started at an almost funereal pace but grew more urgent as it went; and in the final movement, after the ominous church bell interlude, Mr Nelsons marshalled the orchestra for a stirring conclusion that reminded us just how exciting even the most familiar work can sound if played with enough enthusiasm.

Admittedly, the Symphonie fantastique is rarely disappointing, nor are great performances especially hard to come by; the same can be said of Debussy’s Prélude à l’après-midi d’un faune which seems to feature as the overture to at least one concert programme per year. The chance to hear such a rigorously majestic performance of Arcana was more of a rarity, but it was also only one of the concert’s many highlights. One suspects that, if members of the audience end up looking back fondly on this evening, it will be due less to the specific choice of material than to the simple pleasure of hearing a great orchestra, and an inspired conductor, at the very peak of their powers.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.