Alemania
Musikfest 3: Intriguing contrasts
Gustavo Dudamel is certainly no stranger to the podium of the Philharmonie, where he is a frequent guest conductor of the Berlin Philharmonic. At this year’s Musikfest, however, he appeared alongside the Orquesta Sinfónica Simón Bolívar, the Venezuelan orchestra with whom he rose to international prominence, and for whom he still serves as music director. In keeping with the loosely percussive focus of the festival, the programme featured two works from the first half of the twentieth century, both with unconventional or enlarged percussion sections; the curious juxtaposition of Villa-Lobos’ loosely neo-classical Bachianas Brasileiras No. 2 and Messiaen’s epic, forward-thinking Turangalîla-symphonie made for a programme of intriguing contrasts.
The second of Villa-Lobos’ Bachianas Brasileiras – inspired by the dance suites of Bach and scored for a modestly scaled orchestra, augmented by a saxophone and several items of Brazilian percussion – was given a warm, detailed and deeply committed performance with plenty of obvious beauty and a keen sense of forward momentum. While the four pieces which make up the suite are deceptively simple and unerringly pleasant, Mr Dudamel was not afraid to highlight moments of structural and textural interest in a work often dominated by its strong melodies.
Different instruments and groups were given the chance to distinguish themselves as the piece progressed: the opening movement featured a prominent saxophone part, played here with restrained lyricism, while the beginning of the second offered a delightful passage for solo cello. The dialogue between the strings and the small brass section that stands at the centre of the third movement was excitable and robust. Mr Dudamel, conducting without a score, imposed rhythmic discipline on each movement while making sure that the well-crafted melodic lines emerged polished and luxurious; his approach yielded greatest results in the final movement, in which the simple, longing theme in the strings was deepened but never overwhelmed by the contrasting rhythmic and harmonic movement that surrounded it.
The Turangalîla-Symphonie, which followed in the second half, was the first of Messiaen’s vastly scaled works for large orchestra, and the fascination it exerts over the conductors (and audiences) of today is not so different from the effect that Mahler’s large symphonies had on those of the previous generation. The work, on this evening, was given a performance that was often affecting but also somewhat uneven; while there were undoubted moments of grandeur, there were also sections in which Mr Dudamel’s ‘everything all at once’ approach, rather than creating intense excitement, tended to obscure the delicate interplay of the symphony’s recurring themes.
At the top of the evening’s plus column was Jean-Yves Thibaudet, whose performance of the demanding solo-piano part was a source of constant amazement. Mr Thibaudet seems to possess an advanced understanding of the piano’s dual function as both a virtuoso instrument and an element within the orchestral sound-palette, and his ability to embrace the roles of selfless percussionist and star soloist with equal gusto – and to shift between them with so little effort – was very much at the heart of his reading. This was especially apparent in the fourth section (Chant d’amour 2), in which his textural contributions gave way to a breathtaking cadenza, and the ninth section (Turangalîla 3), where his impassioned cascades of notes established the rhythmic centre around which the swirling orchestra could coalesce.
The symphony’s other great solo-part, alas, spent much of the evening frustratingly inaudible. Cynthia Millar is both an excellent Ondes Martenot player and a fine proponent of Messiaen’s work, but on this evening it was often difficult to discern the presence of her instrument. It was not just a question of being lost among the large orchestra: even in the third section (Turangalîla 1) and the languid sixth (Jardin du sommeil d’amour), the Ondes Martenot, which contributes immeasurably to the tranquillity of the quietest passages, seemed unfairly buried. When the instrument did grow more prominent in the final three sections, the high quality of Ms Millar’s playing only highlighted what had been missing to that point.
Sonic balance, in general, was one of the performance’s recurring issues. While the playing from the individual instrumental groups was often excellent – and, in the case of the cellos and basses, the trombones, and the clarinets, quite wonderful – some of the most chaotic full-orchestra passages weren’t quite able to impart clear definition to the musical material. The excitable theme which opens the fifth section (Joie du sang des étoiles) seemed to lack a strong central voice; instead of being driven by a clear dialogue between the strings and brass, one came away with a sense of formlessness, a sense that was only heightened when the sudden appearance of the statue theme united the disparate strands momentarily into an utterance of singular focus.
The evening’s strongest moments were those onto which Mr Dudamel was able to impose the most restraint. The constant alternations between tranquillity and excitement which give the second section (Chant d’amour 1) its structure were beautifully rendered; and in the eighth section (Développement d’amour) Mr Dudamel’s preference for precision over feigned volatility allowed the symphony’s various themes and moods to build toward a natural climax. Indeed, the conclusion of that section, with its bright brass, deep strings and chiming piano, came remarkably close to evoking the imposing magnificence of Messiaen’s most stirring organ works.
If the performance contained a handful of moments that seemed less convincing in their direction, Mr Dudamel’s taut, spirited treatment of the finale brought the piece – and the evening – to a suitably grand conclusion. As the Turangalîla-symphonie gets older, it continues to establish its reputation as one of the more emotionally accessible scores to emerge from the mid-twentieth century, and certainly there appeared to be few in the audience who remained unmoved by its deeply humane vision of the ecstatic.
Comentarios