Alemania

Without Difficulty

Jesse Simon
Without Difficulty
Berlin, miércoles, 28 de septiembre de 2016.
Philharmonie Berlin. Beethoven: Missa solemnis, op. 123. Regine Hangler, soprano, Elisabeth Kulman, alto, Christian Elsner, tenor and Franz-Josef Selig, bass. MDR Rundfunkchor Leipzig. Rundfunk Sinfonieorchester Berlin. Marek Janowski, conductor
0,000117

Beethoven’s Missa solemnis has a reputation for being difficult. Conductors and choral singers will tell you it is difficult to perform; sound engineers will tell you it is difficult to record; record companies will tell you it is difficult to package, with all but the shortest recordings fitting awkwardly over two CDs or four sides of vinyl. And those who grow obsessed with Beethoven’s difficult masterpiece, who acquire every recording and attend every concert they can, must eventually conclude that there has never been and perhaps can never be a definitive performance in which each element comes out exactly right.

Yet even if we accept that perfection – in everything, but especially in the Missa solemnis – is an impossibility, the recent performance given by Marek Janowski and the Rundfunk Sinfonieorchester Berlin was deeply impressive in almost every respect. A refined orchestra, a strong choir, an excellent quartet of soloists and, presiding over everything, Mr Janowski’s assured sense of how everything fit together within the work’s greater structure made for an evening with few obvious flaws and innumerable moments that captured the sublime humanism at the heart of Beethoven’s most ostensibly un-secular work.

The greatest asset of the performance was its unerring sense of balance. There was, simply, nothing that felt out of place. The orchestra achieved a superb, fine-grained sound full of beautiful detail in the strings and understated might in the brass; the MDR choir of Leipzig conveyed a clear idea of Beethoven’s complex part writing – even in the most challenging passages of the ‘Gloria’ and ‘Credo’ – without overshadowing the orchestra or underselling the words. On top of this, the quartet of soloists approached their various ensemble sections with remarkable selflessness, rising above the orchestra at crucial moments while never turning themselves into the centre of attention. Such moderation could have led quite easily to an indifferent or overly polite performance, but the sense of the work’s disparate elements suspended in perfect equilibrium resulted in something unexpectedly thrilling.

The high quality of the performance was apparent from the very beginning. The opening section of the ‘Kyrie’ was taken at a majestic, unhurried pace which allowed ample space for the stirring introduction of the choir, accented gently by the soloists. Yet what proved most impressive about the movement were the effortless surges and swells from the orchestra and choir, the constant rising and falling of sound which, as much as Mr Janowski’s stable pulse, gave the stately ‘Kyrie’ it’s animation and rhythmic tension. Yet any notions that the entire mass was going to proceed in the same measured spirit were quickly dispelled by the vigorous opening of the ‘Gloria’. The unity of the orchestra was just as pronounced – the trumpets especially were notable for their rounded tone and judicious restraint – and the quartet were given an even greater opportunity to demonstrate their vocal chemistry, especially in the ‘Qui tollis peccata mundi’ – in which Elisabeth Kulman made the trickiest of the alto lines sound effortless – and the magnificent fugue near the end.

The ‘Credo’ was, if anything, even more inspired. Tenor Christian Elsner summoned a decisive authority for his exclamations of ‘Et homo factus est’ and the arresting choral introduction to the ‘Et resurrexit’ section provided the movement with a grandly scaled shift in mood. But once again, it was Mr Janowski’s energetic direction and command of tempo that gave the movement its extraordinary sense of form and purpose. The ‘Credo’ passed quickly but lacked none of the dramatic engagement that Beethoven provided for the wordiest section of the Mass ordinary. The bracing choral conclusion, dangerously quick but rendered with absolute clarity, was one of the evening’s most thrilling moments.

The sense of unstoppable momentum that made the ‘Credo’ so compelling didn’t always work to the advantage of the ‘Sanctus’, especially the ‘Benedictus’ section where the pace of the orchestra sometimes seemed to pull against the natural flow of the quartet and made the ‘in nomine Domini’ interjections seem a touch forced. There was still much to like about the movement, not least the woody tone of the strings and the small crescendo in the instrumental prelude to the ‘Benedictus’ that introduced a beautifully played violin solo from concert-master Rainer Wolters.

Bass Franz-Josef Selig, who had spent much of the evening providing a quietly excellent foundation for the various quartet sections, led off the final movement with a series of mournful Misereres accompanied by reverent strings and distant-sounding horns; and when the solemnity of the opening section gave way to the military trumpets and drums, it was Ms. Kulman whose rapturous ‘Agnus dei, qui tollis peccata mundi’ captured the mood of uncontained anticipation leading into the work’s grand finale. In Mr Janowski’s hands, the transition from grand choral exclamations into the rapid instrumental interlude seemed less like an abrupt change than a natural consequence of what had come before; yet in the very final bars he slowed everything back down for a conclusion of maximum grandeur.

According to the programme booklet, a group of engineers from the Pentatone label were on hand to record the evening’s performance for future release. Of course, the ingredients for a thrilling live performance don’t always add up to something that will withstand repeated home listening, but on this evening the combined choral and orchestral forces, presided over by Mr Janowski, generated enough musical chemistry to suggest that their performance of the Missa solemnis might be worth hearing again.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.