Alemania

Freedom and Unity

Jesse Simon
Freedom and Unity
Berlin, lunes, 3 de octubre de 2016.
Schiller Theater. Beethoven: Fidelio. Harry Kupfer, director. Roman Trekel (Don Fernando), Falk Struckmann (Don Pizarro), Andreas Schager (Florestan), Camilla Nylund (Leonore), Matti Salminen (Rocco), Evelin Novak (Marzelline) and Florian Hoffmann (Jaquino). Staatsopernchor Berlin. Staatskapelle Berlin. Daniel Barenboim, conductor
0,0004086

The evening’s greatest surprise came early. After the house lights had dimmed, the first sound to emerge from the darkness was not the familiar figure that opens the overture to Fidelio, but a single mighty chord, underscored by timpani, which receded into an uneasy silence before returning, no less forceful than before. It was, of course, the Leonore overture No. 2, which was used when the opera was first performed in 1805, but later replaced on the advice of his friends with something more concise and upbeat. Just as audiences of the early nineteenth century weren’t quite ready for a twenty-minute fugue as the final movement of a string quartet, they might not have been sure what to do with such an overwhelming prelude to a dramatic work.

The surprise lay not so much in the fact that Daniel Barenboim chose to reinstate the earlier overture – he has been known to do this in the past – but rather in the intensity of his reading. Leonore No. 2 has enjoyed a second life as a concert piece, but the introductory adagio has never sounded so full of malice and foreboding as it did in the darkness of the auditorium on this evening. The pace was slow in the extreme, but the strings created a magnificent tension, drawing us into the ominous subterranean atmosphere of the drama to come. The quiet introduction of the principal theme in the cellos was little short electrifying and the mighty full-orchestra reiteration was easily one of the most thrilling moments of the evening. When the overture at last arrived at its jubilant conclusion the stunned audience, not quite sure what to do, began to applaud, and the orchestra were called to their feet before the opera could begin. Beethoven, as usual, had been right all along. But, in a sense, so were his friends: such a magnificent opening would be difficult to follow.

Harry Kupfer’s new production of Fidelio, which inaugurated the new season at the Staatsoper, could not quite match the high expectations generated in that first quarter hour of overture. His understated, minimal and modernised staging took almost no liberties with the libretto but had a subdued approach to character drama which, very occasionally, suggested an unsettling emptiness at the heart of the story. While the solid and often superb cast did much to illuminate the internal passions of the characters, the real spark of the evening came from Mr Barenboim’s challenging, sometimes idiosyncratic, but often brilliant reading, which offered constant arguments for the dramatic force of Beethoven’s lone opera without ever taking the fabled genius of its composer for granted.

The genius of Beethoven was, to some extent, a theme of Mr Kupfer’s staging. During the overture, a small circle of the otherwise black stage was illuminated to reveal a grand piano with the familiar scowling bust of Beethoven on top; the curtain rose on a backdrop featuring the interior of the Musikverein, which soon fell to the ground revealing the prison in which the action would be set, a minimal and highly stylised set consisting of dark walls which had been covered by the desperate scrawls of innumerable prisoners. The piano and Beethoven remained centre stage until the arrival of Pizarro and his entourage of black-jacketed, jack-booted goons, one of whom attempted to smash the bust but was prevented by Marzelline. Only at the very end were the piano and bust returned to their rightful place and the image of the Musikverein restored. The message was simple and obvious: a life without music is a prison.

Yet this thematic overlay was neither the central argument nor the dramatic focus of the staging. Fidelio is, in some ways, an opera of insular emotions – the characters, at least in the first act, spend as much time talking to themselves as to one another – and Mr Kupfer seemed intent on highlighting the strained relationships that drive the narrative. The trio in the first act featured Rocco physically, although unsuccessfully, attempting to join the hands of Leonore/Fidelio and Marzelline; even the ecstatic overtones of ‘O namenlose Freude’ in the second act were dampened by an almost complete lack of physical interaction between Leonore and Florestan. The closing chorus of the opera may extol the virtues of fidelity and sacrifice, but the ideals of freedom that serve as the opera’s foundation were revealed, in this production at least, to be shaded by a strong undercurrent of individualism. Anyone looking for a straightforward celebration of conjugal unity might have left the opera house unsatisfied.

The introversion of the staging was balanced, to a some extent, by a series of fully engaged performances from an impressive cast with few obvious weaknesses. If Falk Struckmann’s Don Pizarro struggled occasionally to rise above the orchestra – his appearances are, to be fair, accompanied by some of the opera’s most vigorous music – his presence alone was enough to transform his ‘Ha! Welch’ ein Augenblick’ into a chilling character study. There may also have been some in the audience put off by Matti Salminen’s overly gruff Rocco. It is true that Mr Salminen – who revealed himself, in the dialogue sections, to be a naturally gifted actor – brought some of the gravelly-voiced coarseness of his character into his earliest numbers, specifically the quartet and the aria ‘Hat man nicht auch Gold beineben’; yet perhaps more than anyone else, Mr Salminen’s Rocco suggested a fully-realised stage performance.

The figures of Marzelline and Jaquino begin to grow marginal even before the end of the first act as the story veers from domestic melodrama to political intrigue. Yet even within the restricted frame of the early numbers, Evelin Novak delivered an appealing Marzelline, whose gently expressive voice seemed to suggest a confusion underpinned by fear. Her aria – placed before the duet with Jaquino to open the opera – was elegant in its phrasing and convincing in its emotion. Although nervous around her father and Leonore/Fidelio, she had little problem conveying her antipathy toward the Jaquino of Florian Hoffmann, whose strong performance struck a good balance between angry and desperate. There was something in his manner – a possibility that remained underexplored in the staging – to suggest that it would take very little for Jaquino to be drawn into Pizarro’s world of thuggish corruption. Don Fernando, who appears only in the second act finale, is also a peripheral figure within the drama, but Roman Trekel was nonetheless able to convey the well-spoken nobility of the character during his brief time on stage.

It is, of course Leonore and, in the second act, Florestan, who occupy the heart of the drama, and on this evening both received exceptional performances. Camilla Nylund seemed tentative initially, but grew in stature whenever she was able to shed the guise of Fidelio and express herself as Leonore. She sounded a touch underpowered in the first act trio and even in those parts of her aria closer to the lower end of the register; by the middle of the aria, however, she had seized complete control of the drama, and carried it forward to an impassioned conclusion. Her contributions to the second act were even more captivating: an excellent grave-digging scene was followed by an exhilarating reveal in the quartet and capped by a series of ecstatic pronouncements in the final scene which soared majestically above the choir and orchestra.

Andreas Schager has the kind of powerhouse tenor that can make even Siegfried seem effortless, yet his performance as Florestan on this evening was notable as much for its well-considered dramatic contour as its overall heft. His opening ‘Gott, welch’ Dunkel hier’ started hushed, then swelled to fill the auditorium before fading back again. The aria that followed was quite possibly the finest vocal performance of the evening, starting from a point of abject despair but building gradually to a vivid climax as his delirium gives way to visions of freedom. No less compelling were his uncontained exclamations of ‘O namenlose Freude’ and his equally grand praises of Leonore in the finale.

Daniel Barenboim, whose reading of Leonore No. 2 had set the tone for the evening, continued the opera along similar lines, emphasising the tremendous tonal gulf between the dank world of the prison and the enlightenment ideals of the protagonists. There were a handful of passages that didn’t seem to move forward in quite the way anyone was expecting, leading to brief moments of tension between singers (or choir) and orchestra. There were, however, far more sections – the reverent introduction to the ‘O welche Lust’ chorus being an obvious example – that forced one to confront the splendour of Beethoven’s score as if for the first time; in the exceptional final ensemble of the first act finale, one could almost hear the Missa solemnis struggling to emerge. If the staging too often emphasised the dramatic oddities of the libretto, the consistently wonderful playing of Staatskapelle under Mr Barenboim left us in no doubt about the majestic formal unity achieved in Beethoven’s score.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.