Alemania
From common ground to lofty heights
Christian Thielemann and Rudolf Buchbinder appear to approach the same music from opposite extremes of temperament. Mr Thielemann, with his large gestures, occasionally stiff demeanour and frequent look of consternation, creates the impression of someone searching and striving, forever attempting to convince the orchestra to make a pianissimo that much quieter or a climax even more profound; yet the music that emerges is more often than not possessed of considerable sensitivity and refinement, with few of the conductorly idiosyncrasies that one might expect from such an apparently physical involvement with the score.
Mr Buchbinder, on the other hand, cloaks the fiery aspects of his performance beneath a surface of total placidity; yet the geniality of his presence, the quiet assurance of his technique, and the economy of his gestures can reveal great consequences. At a recent concert with the Berlin Philharmonic – one of Mr Thielemann’s two guest appearances with the orchestra in December – the two musicians found an ample and often satisfying middle ground in a performance of Beethoven’s First Piano Concerto, the first half of a programme which also included an extraordinary reading of Bruckner’s Seventh. This particular meeting of conductor, orchestra and soloist resulted in a convincingly grand Beethoven sound, in which the sparkling texture of the piano was almost always surrounded by luxuriant warmth.
The pace set by Mr Thielemann for the first movement was not unnaturally slow, but it had a spacious elegance that made the initial flurry of notes produced by Mr Buchbinder seem all the more surprising. Yet Mr Buchbinder’s fleet and seemingly effortless traversals of the keyboard never seemed unaligned with the pulse of the orchestra. Although his approach to the solo part had an effervescent lightness and a precision that could seem overly polished, his subtle moments of emphasis and careful turns of phrase conveyed a satisfying depth. The cadenza in particular was notable for its articulation and fluidity.
The second movement was exceptional, languid and soft but with a persistence of momentum and a subtle undercurrent of restlessness. Mr Buchbinder approached the calm phrases and delicate interstitial trills with total composure, leaving it to Mr Thielemann and the orchestra to provide the movement with its dramatic shading. Then, after only the briefest of pauses, Mr Buchbinder introduced the Rondo with an exuberant flourish and the orchestra, urged on my Mr Thielemann’s forceful enactment of the rhythm, followed with a triumphant sound possessed of considerable muscle in the lower strings and prominent rolls of thunderous timpani; and while it was Mr Buchbinder’s deft touch that propelled the movement toward a moment of quiet resolution, it was the rich tone of the orchestra that gave the concerto it’s thrillingly decisive conclusion.
Bruckner’s symphonies have long been central to Mr Thielemann’s repertoire, and his performances – either with the Staatskapelle Dresden or as a guest with the Berlin Philharmonic – are always notable for their structural insight and presiding gravity, but also for their emotional immediacy. Yet while his reading of the soaring first movement and the mighty second had no trouble reaching the sublime heights that one might have expected, what distinguished his performance on this evening was his treatment of the Finale. Where some conductors can make the symphony feel front-loaded, pouring their energies into the opening movements while speeding through the final two as though they were somehow of lesser value, Mr Thielemann’s thoughtful, detailed account of the fourth resulted in a conclusion that seemed in every way worthy of the symphony that preceded it.
Mr Thielemann, who conducted without a score, has the ability to play Bruckner very slowly without sacrificing any sense of purpose. This was especially apparent during the first movement, in which his subtle shifts in tempo, usually used to reveal details of orchestration, never seemed to interrupt the flow. The orchestra, under his direction, sounded refined but never glib; in the final bars of the first movement – slowed down for maximum intensity – magnificent clouds of horns and trombones rose gracefully above an ecstatic exclamation from the massed strings. Anyone who turns to Bruckner for grandeur could not have been disappointed by such a majestic conclusion.
The agitated second movement offered more in the way of external anguish than inner struggle. It also featured some of the evening’s most impressive playing from the individual sections, with emphatic cellos, elegant flutes, consistently rich trombones and, of course, highly disciplined work from the orchestra’s team of Wagner tuba players. Although the movement’s first climactic moment threatened to become unbalanced by the brass, the slow build to the grand climax was a thing of wonder; Mr Thielemann’s unerring confidence in setting the funereal theme against the ascending violin triplets created a magnificent tension that could only be resolved in an explosion of sound. And yet, when the sound had subsided, Mr Thielemann was able to locate a profound calm within the coda, coming eventually to rest on a sturdy, smouldering chord held by the Wagner tubas.
After such tranquillity, the scherzo seemed almost unnaturally quick and, during its course, one could hear some changes both in pace and dynamic that were less than subtle. Yet the Finale, with its great attention to structural detail, its measured pacing and its superbly controlled exclamations from the full orchestra suggested that Bruckner’s concluding movement, if not quite the equal of the first two in terms of dramatic intensity, was certainly more substantial than some readings might lead one to believe. While the final moments of Bruckner’s Seventh are always thrilling to hear in the concert hall, between the direction of Mr Thielemann and the attentive playing of the orchestra, one was awed not merely by the natural majesty of the conclusion but also by the striking sense of formal balance.
Comentarios