Alemania
Unnatural Acts
The new opera Edward II – which recently had its world première at the Deutsche Oper – is a mere ninety minutes in length, but composer Andrea Lorenzo Scartazzini and librettist Thomas Jonigk have managed to fit more discomfort into its brief duration than many musical dramatists will manage in a lifetime. It is a work of profound sexual anxiety and corporeal revulsion propelled by a dazzling, often unsettling score which scatters shards of conventional dissonance over ominous rumbles and surround-sound hisses. Yet for all its lines of unprintable dialogue and scenes of shocking violence, it is neither gratuitous nor inaccessible; beneath its tactics of provocation, one finds the familiar presence of a classic tragedy.
Mr Jonigk’s taut libretto – drawn loosely from Marlowe’s famous play, along with Holinshed’s Chronicles (Marlowe’s principal source) and a Latin chronicle possibly written in the final year of Edward’s reign – largely dispenses with external political machinations, choosing instead to condense the narrative of Edward’s downfall into a feverish tale of escalating madness. Although both Marlowe and the earlier historians tended to be ambiguous or allusive when discussing Edward’s relationship with Piers Gaveston, the opera takes Edward’s homosexuality as a given. Yet the action of Edward II often seems less interested in questions of sexual orientation than in the repressive, conformist atmosphere of the court, which transforms Edward’s life into a kind of prison.
The opera opens on a particularly barbarous note: a mob invades Edward’s chambers and forces him to enact a crude ‘marriage’ with Gaveston, who appears beaten half to death in a bloody wedding dress. The sequence, along with several others that follow, is both dream and premonition, a reflection of the anxieties that will blossom into madness. Edward’s relationship with Gaveston, which has already alienated his wife Isabella, is widely understood but largely unspoken in the English court; yet Edward, convinced that his homosexuality will be used as a political tool against him, begins to remove his enemies from power, starting with the Bishop of Coventry who has been fuelling a popular revolt with his inflammatory anti-gay sermons. His efforts are ultimately in vain: after being deposed by his wife and the power-hungry Roger Mortimer, his lover is killed and he is placed in prison to await execution.
Although the action is relentless, it provides a few moments of relief in the form of two male characters – they appear as soldiers, councillors, ministers and prisoners, but always performed by the same two singers – whose attempts to prove their straightness invariably result either in an awkward homosexual encounter or a brutal overcompensation in the opposite direction. These interludes of dark comedy are a crucial extension of the opera’s central argument: the nominally straight characters make repeated reference to the ‘unnatural acts’ associated with homosexuality … yet the atrocities committed by these characters in the name of maintaining a heterosexual status quo are revealed to be far more unnatural.
Director Christof Loy started the action in high gear and allowed few moments of respite to intrude upon the sweeping tableaux of mob brutality and spare-but-intense moments of internal struggle. Yet the force of the opera came as often from Mr Scartazzini’s fascinatingly textural score. Swarms of muted strings and flurries of arrhythmic percussion were augmented by a synthesizer and a pre-recorded magnetic tape which, at crucial moments, filled the hall with the sensation of an incessant wordless whispering. Although Mr Scartazzini’s orchestral treatments seemed intent on exploring the outer limits of instrumental technique – there were entire sections in which the drama seemed to be propelled by blocks of sound completely adrift from any conventional notion of pitch – much of the vocal writing was possessed of great lucidity. Isabella’s ghostly dream monologue in the first scene was extraordinary by any standard, and the wordless passage taken up by Isabella, the spirit of Gaveston and the Angel just before Edward’s death came as close to beauty as the opera was willing to get.
Mr Scartazzini’s score was brought to life by strong performances both on the stage and below it. In the title role, Michael Nagy provided a vivid and compelling delineation of Edward’s madness; his expressive voice was matched with an unrelenting physical intensity which reached its peak in a moving scene where Edward was forced to dispatch Gaveston to Ireland. However it was Agneta Eichenholz who, as Isabella, brought a voice of crystalline clarity and room-filling power to two of the opera’s most arresting scenes: the first, an explicit description of a dream, and the second, a lament of sorts culminating in an implied seduction of Mortimer, combined to position Isabella as the work’s most immediately sympathetic character, whose resigned suffering provided a necessary counterpoint to Edward’s frenzied confusion.
Burkhard Ulrich gave a commanding performance as the Bishop of Coventry, whose over-zealous, Leviticus-quoting homophobia was more Westboro Baptist Church than Westminster Abbey; and Andrew Harris was pleasingly severe as Mortimer, delivering each line with a mixture of self-importance and haughty disgust for everything around him. Although nominally supporting players, the duo of Markus Brück and Gideon Poppe – who appeared as the soldiers, ministers, etc. – approached their roles with scene-stealing gusto. Not only did they provide the evening with its few precious moments of comedic relief, but they also infused the opera with a humanity sometimes lacking in the world of the courtly figures; in an opera filled with violence, their second meeting, as councillors, was all the more shocking for its sudden and immense sadness.
Conductor Thomas Søndergård directed the orchestra in an exacting performance which both highlighted the textural details in the score and matched the intensity of the action. The high woodwinds produced fearsome metallic exclamations and the double basses conjured otherworldly beds of sound, but it was the team of percussionists who delivered the evening’s most heroic playing. The vast array of gongs, woodblocks, and random noisemakers (including something that sounded suspiciously like a whirly tube) all contributed immeasurably to the opera’s deeply compelling sound-world.
While the technical demands of its score and the explicit treatment of its central themes gave Edward II a veneer of extreme modernity, its use of royal figures from history to illuminate problems in the present day placed it squarely within an immediately recognisable tradition stretching back to classical antiquity. The king’s inability to reconcile his private desires with the public expectations of society made Edward II a timely tragedy for the twenty-first century; and as with all edifying tragedies, it left the audience in no doubt as to how its tragic outcome could have been avoided.
Comentarios