Alemania
Erik’s Trip
In a season which has thus far involved a world première and a high-profile new entry in an ongoing Meyerbeer cycle, the arrival of a new production of Wagner’s ever-popular Der fliegende Holländer at the Deutsche Oper seemed curiously low-key. Yet the alignment of a thoughtful staging, a solid cast, an exceptional performance from the choir, and an energetic, beautifully-fashioned reading from Donald Runnicles resulted in an evening of dramatic coherence and consistent musical delight.
Director Christian Spuck’s staging managed to be conceptually satisfying without overextending its concept or testing Wagner’s libretto to destruction. It was also, in its own gloomy way, quite beautiful. The atmospheric and largely monochromatic set (by Rufus Didwiszus) was essentially a large, dank room with two faintly discernable double-doors toward the rear of the stage. The area surrounding the doors was submerged beneath an inch or two of water, which resulted in much splashing every time the choir appeared, but also, with the help of restrained lighting and a large cloud of low-hanging stage fog, suggested the inescapable dampness of the setting far more convincingly than many productions.
If the stage itself offered a pared-down version of the story’s locations – the elegant transformation in the second act, with a terraced mound of sewing machines and fabric walls suggesting an interior, did little to dispel the prevailing mood of scarcity – Mr Spuck was able to generate near-constant visual interest primarily through rigorously choreographed crowd scenes and well-considered approaches to the individual characters. At the centre of the drama was Erik. Although the story has Erik appear for only two (admittedly crucial) scenes, in this production he remained onstage from the opening bars of the overture to the final notes of the third act, sometimes observing the characters, sometimes engaging with them, other times simply expressing his rage at the water. As the opera unfolded, it became clear that what we were watching was, in fact, the events as they replayed themselves in Erik’s tortured imagination; the death of his beloved may have happened long ago, but the memories continued to haunt him on an endless loop.
The idea that everything was filtered through Erik’s grief resulted in several fascinating moments of characterisation. The Dutchman himself appeared not as a robust sea-hardened man, but as a moribund figure continually collapsing from the weight of his curse. The central meeting of Senta and the Dutchman, in which the two occupied the same physical space without ever seeming to engage or interact with one another, offered the subtle yet plausible suggestion that the Dutchman – and by extension the cause of Senta’s death – existed only in her imagination. With Erik on the sidelines, attempting to make sense of Senta’s obsession, the opera became less a parable of eternal fidelity than a post-mortem search for signs of mental illness.
In the role of Erik, Thomas Blondelle rose to the considerable challenge of the production’s dramatic demands. The uncontained rage that erupted during his moments of observation was channelled into a superbly acted vocal performance in his two scenes with Senta. One could hear, in his remonstrations, a constantly shifting mix of anger, despair and sorrow. In an opera where much is foreordained, Mr Blondelle sang with the extra urgency of someone who knew how everything would turn out, even if he did not quite realise he was powerless to stop it.
The drama may revolve around Erik, Senta and the Dutchman, but on this evening it was the Daland of Tobias Kehrer who gave the story its core of humanity. Mr Kehrer’s radiant, unfailingly warm tone, coupled with a natural charisma, turned Daland’s every appearance into a highlight. His frustrated desire to reach home in the opening scene was offset by a good natured fatalism, and his delightful appearance in the second act, introducing the Dutchman to his daughter, was infused with great affection.
Next to Mr Kehrer, Samuel Youn’s Dutchman was both lighter and steelier in tone, but there was a pliant quality to his voice that lent itself to the dramatic outbursts of his first act monologue and elsewhere conveyed the drawn, tormented exhaustion of the character. The negotiation with Daland at the end of the first act was pleasingly differentiated, although his central duet with Senta seemed puzzlingly detached: the two never quite locked together in a convincing manner. If there were a handful of moments that demanded more commanding heft, Mr Youn’s performance was undoubtedly well-matched to Mr Spuck’s conception of the character.
Ingela Brimberg provided the evening with a spirited and wholly compelling realisation of Senta. Although her fulsome high notes at the end of the second act duet – and in her highly charged final scene – were undeniably impressive, it was her ease with the lower-lying passages that allowed her to unfurl a gripping and wonderfully structured narration of the Dutchman’s plight. At the opening of the second act, Senta was given richly voiced reprimands by the Mary of Ronnita Miller; and as the helmsman, Matthew Newlin delivered an excellent song to the south wind.
Donald Runnicles, fresh from two complete Ring cycles in April, delivered quite possibly his finest Wagner performance in recent memory, a marvel of flawless dramatic pacing and, with the exception of a few moments in the overture where the brass threatened to overwhelm the strings, consummate orchestral balance. The strings were in especially fine form throughout the evening, adding folk-dance earthiness to the spinning chorus at the beginning of the second act, and conjuring splendid agitation at the first appearance of the Dutchman’s ship.
The vigour of the orchestra was matched by an exceptional performance from the men of the Deutsche Oper choir; their hearty yo-ho-ing in the first act was impressive for its richness of sound, but it was only a prelude to the opening of the third act, in which the call and response between Daland’s sailors and the Dutchman’s phantom crew provided the evening with one of its most hauntingly memorable moments. The women of the choir, who brought excitability to the opening of the second act and joined with the sailors for a lusty celebration at the beginning of the third, were no less impressive.
Although Mr Spuck’s production offered little in the way of last-minute redemption – it ended much as it began, with Erik alone on stage attempting to make sense of everything that had happened – one nonetheless emerged from the auditorium with the sense of elation that comes whenever one of Wagner’s scores is given an especially eloquent performance. Der fliegende Holländer may lack the intensified drama and epic stature of Wagner’s later works but, on this evening, the strong production and inspired performances offered clear insight into the work’s particular charm.
Comentarios