Alemania
A Late-Season Highlight
, Berlin
1 July 2017
Reviewed by Jesse Simon
The Pierre Boulez Saal, which opened in March of this year, was designed primarily for smaller ensembles: its capacity (around 700), its in-the-round seating, and its fine-grained acoustic offer a level of proximity to both the music and the performers that is rare even in a more traditional chamber music space. Yet the hall, it turns out, is equally suited to a classically-sized orchestra, and the opportunity to hear three of Schubert’s early symphonies in such an intimate setting proved to be one of the undisputed highlights of Berlin’s recently-ended concert season.
As part of the Boulez Saal’s ongoing exploration of Schubert’s music – which has already featured the piano sonatas and will, in the coming years, include the complete string quartets and a survey of the songs – the Staatskapelle Berlin under the direction of Daniel Barenboim performed two complete cycles of the eight numbered symphonies. The second concert of the second cycle, which placed the tempestuous Fourth between the radiant Fifth and the joyous Sixth was both a satisfying programme and an evening of exceptional music-making, which also happened to feature quite possibly the finest performance of the Fifth Symphony this reviewer has ever heard.
The room itself was undoubtedly a contributing factor. Of Schubert’s symphonies, the Fifth is the most modestly scored, and the sonic clarity offered by the auditorium was close to ideal for the scale of the orchestra. The twenty-three persons string section provided a robust, warm, and deeply nuanced sound, gently enhanced at crucial moments by subtle accents from the two horns; and in the Boulez Saal, where no one on the ground level was further than about a dozen feet from the nearest musician, one could both see and hear the finest details of orchestration that might get lost in a larger concert hall.
Yet the performance would have been extraordinary in any space. On the surface, Mr Barenboim’s reading of the Fifth was perhaps the most conservative of the evening: it made the fewest leaps, took the fewest chances and offered the fewest obvious interpretive flourishes. It was also, in its own way, perfect. The tempi were a model of good judgment, lively but unhurried, revealing both the exquisite details and the gently propulsive inner rhythms of the score. The buoyant first movement, especially, was driven forward by an infectious spontaneity.
Mr Barenboim never allowed the second movement to coast on its own charm; although the principal theme was beautifully shaped – perhaps nowhere more so than in its quiet final appearance – the mood of pastoral calm was underscored with a sense of quiet reverence. The third movement, on the other hand, found drama in the tension between the severity of the opening theme and the effervescent foundation against which it unfolded. Schubert’s Fifth is always a delight, but this performance radiated a sense of quiet confidence and extraordinary internal balance that one hears only on rare occasions.
The addition of clarinets, trumpets, extra horns and timpani for the Fourth symphony resulted in a full orchestra sound of considerably greater density, although even the imposing tuttis of the first movement retained their clarity. As in the previous symphony, the tempi were close to ideal: Mr Barenboim did not go out of his way to heighten the contrast between the first movement’s Adagio introduction and its subsequent Allegro section – nor did he break into a gallop for the transition into the C major coda; the second movement was never allowed to meander, and the Menuetto was given its distinctive edge from the incisive attack of the strings. Only in the symphony’s final movement did one have the sense that Mr Barenboim was pushing the orchestra toward the upper limits of Allegro; yet the brisk pace created a nervous energy that carried the symphony toward a thrilling conclusion.
After the grace of the Fifth and the drama of the Fourth, the Sixth – which channels the same youthful exuberance as the Third – can seem like something of a throwback. Yet while it is undoubtedly a work of good humour, on this evening Mr Barenboim approached its light-heartedness seriously, highlighting its larger gestures and, in the Scherzo especially, drawing subtle parallels with Schubert’s other, more ambitious C major symphony. Although the size of the orchestra had not changed since the Fourth, they responded to Mr Barenboim’s cues – in the second movement he seemed to be conducting as much with his eyes as his baton – with a heavier, more portentous sound. Indeed, it was the depth of orchestral tone as much as anything else that pointed most clearly toward Schubert’s future symphonies.
Fortunately this newfound gravity did not come at the expense of agility. The strings remained as detailed as they had been for the first two symphonies, and the interplay of the flutes and oboes – which had been such a constant delight throughout the Fourth and Fifth symphonies – continued to be one of the evening’s greatest strengths. Mr Barenboim took the final movement at a pace that seemed slow – although never exaggerated or unnatural – but that kept the work’s good nature in sharp focus.
There did not appear to be any recording equipment set up in the hall, which is something of a shame: not only would the performances – especially of the evening’s first two symphonies – have made a worthy addition to the Schubert discography, but it would also be interesting to hear how the acoustic of the Boulez Saal sounds on record. Then again, it is hard to imagine a recording that could capture the sensation of being in the same room as – and so thrillingly close to – an orchestra and a conductor at the height of their powers.
Comentarios