Estados Unidos
Santa Fe Opera 4: Dodon’s Downfall
The Golden Cockerel, like so many of Rimsky-Korsakov’s operas, features dazzling orchestration, passages of superb writing for the female voice, and a fairy-tale atmosphere with political undercurrents. Although it is marginally less of a rarity outside Russia than some of his other works, it remains largely neglected in the West, and the opportunity to see it performed as part of this summer’s Santa Fe Opera season was most welcome. While Paul Curran’s visually striking but dramatically uneven production obscured some of the story’s more intriguing possibilities, a stunning performance from Venera Gimadieva as the Queen of Shemakha offered ample proof of Rimsky-Korsakov’s mastery of the operatic fable.
The story, adapted from Pushkin by Vladimir Belsky, takes place in a far-off land which is under threat from an even further-off land. (With its central exotic dance and its ineffectual ruler making a promise he is loathe to honour, the story also contained more than a few echoes of Strauss’ Salome which had first appeared in Dresden only two years earlier; the similarities may have been coincidental, but they were intriguing nonetheless). Despite its fabulous setting – and perhaps because the performance coincided with a day of escalating tensions between the US and North Korea – the political resonances were obvious: the Tsar even suggests building a wall around his country, while one of his sons pushes for a pre-emptive strike. Mr Curran’s staging chose to keep the overt political content largely in the background, opting instead for a highly literal, if occasionally somewhat abstract fairy-tale reading. Yet for all its vivid costumes and too-the-letter inclusion of stage props, it often struggled to establish the right tone for its subject.
The first act in particular tried too hard to situate the opera as a comedy of buffoonery. The narcoleptic, overweight Tsar Dodon ruled from an oversized throne that doubled as a day bed, while his two sons bickered and slap-fought like five-year-olds, and the chorus of advisors leaned backward and wrung their hands in synchronised exaggeration. With a lighter touch it might have been amusing, but the timing was laborious and everything seemed slightly forced. Rimsky-Korsakov himself suggested that the actors on stage should not try to draw attention to themselves when not singing and, on the evidence of the opening scene, he may have been onto something.
Things improved considerably in the second act: the image of the Tsar’s forces stuck in a mountain pass vaguely aware of an unseen enemy evoked palpable suspense, and the sudden, magical arrival of the Queen of Shemakha was genuinely inspired. Yet the action that followed suggested an uncertainty about the very focus of the story. The production seemed unwilling to pose a specific argument regarding the Queen’s motives, and her attempts to seduce the Tsar using the hypnotic power of song and dance came across as somewhat baffling. In attempting to ensure a constant visual interest on the stage, the production glossed over some of the subtleties of character that might have given the story greater dramatic weight.
It did, however, look great. The slightly psychedelic Russian-inspired robes of the Tsar’s advisors also helped to convey a sense of the fantastic, and the set, which consisted of a large swooping steel structure – it may have been conceived by a skateboarder during an acid trip –resembled a bird’s wing in the first act, but was broken into sharper fragments in the second to create the mountain pass; should the Santa Fe Opera ever attempt a Ring cycle, they could easily reuse the set for Brünnhilde’s rock. The curved surface doubled as a screen for video projections including, most prominently, the titular bird, oddly one of the few elements of the story which did not appear on the stage in physical form. (On this evening, a particularly spectacular New Mexico sunset made the bird very difficult to see during the first act … but the sunset was so beautiful there were few complaints).
However it was the arrival of the Queen of Shemakha early in the second act that elevated the production almost single-handedly. From her first words, Venera Gimadieva suggested someone who had arrived not so much from another land, but from a completely different opera. Although she had several longer passages interspersed with reactions from the Tsar and his General – in one she described her homeland in rapturously mythic terms, and in another she detailed her own physical beauty – the impression left by the second act was of a single hypnotic aria filled with unconventional, exotic melody and beautifully winding ornamentation. Ms Gimadieva’s pure, majestically rounded tone – it seemed to float into the audience fully-formed, propelled by unseen forces – was far more dazzling than any of the costumes or projections, and whenever she was singing it was easy to forgive the inconsistencies of the production.
As the Tsar’s housekeeper Amelfa, Meredith Arwady was a delight. Her exacting delivery and powerful, seemingly-limitless lower register transformed her scene bringing food to the Tsar into a high point of the first act. As the bumbling Dodon, Tim Mix seemed at odds with the production’s constant attempts to diminish the stature of its central character. The few moments when Mr Mix allowed himself to break free of the production’s strictures revealing the powerful ruler behind the unconvincing fat-suit were by far the most compelling, and one couldn’t help but feel that the evening might have benefitted from allowing him to bring more authority to the role. The high, resonant tenor of Barry Banks – somewhere between heroic and mocking – gave the Astrologer a pleasingly mischievous distinction; Kevin Burdette brought considerable energy to the hawkish, moustachioed General Polkan; and Kasia Borowiec, who remained offstage, gave the titular bird an arresting urgency.
The highly refined, occasionally restrained playing of the Santa Fe Opera orchestra under the direction of Emmanuel Villaume may not have been ideally suited to the few intrusions of fiery folk-dance rhythms, but the score’s most haunting passages were exquisite. Rimsky-Korsakov was a master of mood, and Mr Villaume ensured that the ominous tension in the mountain pass, the Queen’s evocation of an otherworldly paradise, and the intimations of madness and catastrophe that accompanied the return of Dodon and the Queen to the capital were realised with the requisite elegance and depth.
One of the more common reactions to seeing any of Rimsky-Korsakov’s operas is a desire to see more of them, and this year’s Santa Fe production of The Golden Cockerel was no exception. One may have wished for a more clearly articulated vision of the story, a more detailed elaboration of its thematic undercurrents, or even a more haunting evocation of its dark mood, but the evening’s orchestral and vocal performances went a long way toward illustrating the particular genius of its composer.
Comentarios