Estados Unidos

Santa Fe Opera 5: Grand Conclusions

Jesse Simon
Santa Fe Opera 5: Grand Conclusions
Santa Fe, sábado, 12 de agosto de 2017.
Santa Fe Opera. Donizetti: Lucia di Lammermoor. Ron Daniels, director. Brenda Rae (Lucia), Zachary Nelson (Enrico), Mario Chang (Edgardo), Christian Van Horn (Raimondo), Sarah Coit (Alisa), Carlos Santelli (Arturo) and Stephen Martin (Normanno). Chorus and Orchestra of the Santa Fe Opera. Corrado Rovaris, conductor
0,0002863

After a world première (Steve Jobs), a light entertainment (Fledermaus), a rarity (The Golden Cockerel), and an excursion into the baroque period (Alcina), Lucia di Lammermoor was conspicuous as the token ‘grand classic’, a tightly plotted, craftily composed soprano showcase replete with ill-fated love and a reasonably high death toll. It may also have been the finest production at this summer’s Santa Fe Opera season. The staging was pleasingly subtle and the principals were excellent, but it was Brenda Rae’s transcendent performance of the title role that turned the evening into something close to an event.

The highly understated, almost imperceptibly subtle staging by Ron Daniels created what appeared to be a neutral environment in which the vocal performances could flourish; but as the evening progressed, the staging revealed its psychological depths and narrative mastery, all without ever really drawing attention to itself. Last year on the very same stage, Mr Daniels had presented an oddly low-key Don Giovanni that seemed to go through the motions without offering much in the way of insight, argument, or even basic engagement with the characters, and on the strength of Lucia’s remarkably static opening chorus one might have expected more of the same. Yet while Mr Daniels did have a tendency to concentrate the action at the very front of the stage, and some of the physical movement seemed to be pulled from an antiquated playbook of operatic mannerism, the subsequent scenes revealed a coherent vision of the characters and their conflicting desires.

If anything, the staging may have been too subtle: Mr Daniels worked for the most part in small gestures and fleeting allusion – a single, casual moment hinting at possible incest between Lucia and Enrico was all the more chilling for being passed over without comment – which caused the larger, more obviously dramatic scenes to seem untended. If Mr Daniels did have an interpretive vision – and one suspects he did – he was wholly unconcerned with spelling it out. However his penchant for understatement somewhat mitigated the opera’s capacity for high melodrama, and by the end one was left with the sensation of a carefully planned, honestly wrought tragedy.

Mr Daniels, to his great credit, also seemed to have considerable faith in the ability of the singers to fill the dramatic spaces created by the staging; and in the course of the evening there was hardly a weak performance to be found. Much of the attention was focused on Brenda Rae, whose Lucia had more than a hint of greatness to it. From her first appearance, awaiting Edgardo by the fountain, Ms Rae announced that she had the vocal presence to carry the evening. Her crisp enunciation, confident leaps to the high notes and magnificent swells were individually as impressive as her ability to endow a line with dramatic form, adding subtle gradations of power and intensity on her way to the climactic point.

A staircase emerged from the back of the stage in the second act (in this production the first two acts were combined, and the third act was presented as the second) allowing Ms Rae to make a grand entrance for the famous ‘mad scene’, performed with captivating grace and total technical command. The scene was made all the more mesmerising by the presence of an actual glass harmonica in the orchestra pit; the fine performance from Friedrich Heinrich Kern echoed Lucia’s exclamations with an otherworldly ringing. Ms Rae, however, saved her finest singing for her very final moments which continued to build in excitement and tension until her fatal collapse. If there were a few instances throughout the evening where her physical actions could seem a touch mannered, it was a minor point in a performance that was otherwise close to flawless.

Ms Rae alone would have made the evening a memorable success, but she was surrounded by a cast of considerable strength. Edgardo was given doomed immediacy through the bold, passionate tenor of Mario Chang. Although there were a few early moments where his delivery seemed a touch metrical – notably ‘Sulla tomba che rinserra’ – Mr Chang grew more natural and more noteworthy as the evening progressed. His appearance at Lucia’s wedding reception caused ripples of excitement, his fiery manner in his duet with Enrico was capped by an arrestingly large high note, and his final dying aria brought the evening to a suitably grand conclusion.

Christian Van Horn, who had also appeared in Alcina as the tutor Melisso, gave a superb performance as the chaplain Raimondo; as the opera’s lone voice of sanity and conciliation, he was a decisive presence during the wedding scene, and his narration of Arturo’s wedding-night death was thrilling in its severity. As the angry, vengeful Enrico, Zachary Nelson was wonderfully sinister: in his three finest scenes – his opening-scene attempts to discover the identity of Lucia’s lover, his presentation of the forged letter, and his challenge to Edgardo – he conveyed the cold determination of a man following the script of his own fate. With the addition of Carlos Santelli as the short-lived Arturo and the Sarah Coit as the perpetually frightened Alisa, the sextet at the end of the first half proved magnificent.

Under the direction of Corrado Rovaris, the orchestra alternated passages of gentle understatement and near-Verdian fury, while retaining Donizetti’s essential refinement and economy of manner. Like the production itself, the Mr Rovaris’ reading rarely drew attention to itself, but remained balanced and well-judged throughout the evening. Like the production, it was also able to create a space in which the singers could flourish; and Lucia di Lammermoor undoubtedly belongs to that particular family of operas (see also Il Trovatore) that can transcend its melodramatic source on the strength of its singers alone.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.