Alemania
Musikfest 3: Trans-Alpine Express
Riccardo Chailly has appeared in Berlin several times over the past few years, but this evening marked his first visit with the Filarmonica della Scala since taking up his new position as their chief conductor in 2015. The evening’s programme, with its first half devoted to Brahms and its second to Verdi, may have been reasonably conservative by the standards of Musikfest, but one could hardly complain: there was tremendous satisfaction to be found in hearing these grand classics given nobly spirited performances by such an excellent orchestra.
The first movement of Brahms’ Violin Concerto is infused with great severity and one of the questions facing any interpreter is precisely how much of its internal struggle should be brought to the fore. On this evening, Leonidas Kavakos seemed initially resistant to admitting anything more than a trace of drama and, as a result, the opening came across as slightly cool. The technical precision in the playing was a marvel in itself – the volley of rapid notes and broken chords in the first solo section were presented with total clarity and flawless intonation – but the casual perfection, at least for much of the first movement, had a slightly hermetic quality; one occasionally longed for the notes be invested with greater emotional heft.
The dazzling archness of the solo part was offset to some extent by the warmth of the orchestra, whose string section had a woody mid-range richness, perfectly complemented by the slight prominence of the woodwinds and the subtle glow of the brass. The gentle cresting and subsiding gave even the most solemn moments a sense of fluidity, and Mr Chailly proved an ideal accompanist, never overplaying or drawing attention to his own contributions, but ensuring that the orchestra remained a distinctive presence throughout the piece.
The particular logic of Mr Kavakos’ reading grew more apparent during the first movement cadenza, which started from a point of almost rigorous calm but soon developed into something more fascinating. His use of silences and near silences to punctuate the showier passages became increasingly captivating and the audience responded with a level of rapt attention that seemed unusual even for the Philharmonie. This inspiration carried over to the second movement, which would stand as the high point of the performance. If the first movement had been frustrating for its austere virtuosity, the lyrical passages of the second showcased Mr Kavakos’ ability to shape long, elegant phrases with great nobility.
In the finale, the orchestra played with a considered monumentality that might have sounded a touch rigid on its own, but it was illuminated by the sparkling assurance of Mr Kavakos whose wry precision was mixed with an animation that had been missing from the first movement. After an energetic conclusion, Mr Kavakos returned for an encore performance of the Sarabande from Bach’s D minor Partita which, while not especially slow, maintained a meditative expansiveness that was anything but cursory.
The evening’s all-Verdi second half opened with the overture to I Vespri Siciliani, an undemanding pleasure enjoyed, it seemed, as much by the conductor and orchestra as the audience. The opening section was a master-class in building suspense by degrees, the middle passage was played with an appropriately Verdian fury – the percussionists, especially, were superb – and the final moments avoided all sentimentality while suggesting the epic sweep of its parent opera. It was a rousing, if somewhat misleading prelude for the two sombre pieces that followed.
Verdi’s Quattro pezzi sacri often appear on concert programmes as a single group, but the practice of extracting one or two is certainly not uncommon. On this evening, Mr Chailly omitted the two pieces scored only for choir and presented a solemn Stabat Mater followed by a frequently luminous Te Deum. While the Brahms had been notable for its restraint, Mr Chailly and the orchestra seemed more willing to lean into the dynamic contrasts of the Stabat Mater, resulting in several moments of bracing drama along with one or two that seemed a touch unfocussed. However the Rundfunkchor demonstrated their capacity for fearful swells and lucid forte passages, and when they were fully locked in with the orchestra the results were gratifyingly imposing.
The potential for synergy between choir and orchestra was more fully realised in the Te Deum, which opened with a breathtakingly serene a capella section before launching itself toward the vastness with a mighty, room-filling ‘Sanctus’. Mr Chailly’s pacing seemed more intuitively spontaneous than in the previous piece, bringing urgency to the opening sections, but settling into a more deliberate, more spacious mode as the piece worked its way toward its climax, allowing the shimmering layers of choir and orchestra to emerge with vivid clarity; in the quietly majestic ‘Miserere nostri’ section, the orchestra seemed to glow from within.
After much applause, Mr Chailly returned for an encore that seemed almost foreordained. The overture to La forza del destino was perhaps the least surprising piece they could have chosen, and the brisk pace of the opening brass chords suggested that this would be little more than a cursory run-through of a well worn crowd-pleaser; yet as it progressed, it became something considerably greater. Much as they had done all evening, Mr Chailly and the Filarmonica della Scala demonstrated that there were still plenty of delights and surprises to be found in even the most familiar of pieces.
Comentarios