Alemania
Pacifists and Activists
After the success of Einstein on the Beach, Satyagraha was a logical next step for Philip Glass. Although the score continued to mine a similar arpeggiated dream-world, he replaced the electric organs with the strings and woodwinds of a more conventional orchestra, and moved from numbers and solfège syllables to an actual sung text, albeit in the highly vocalic Sanskrit language. Satyagraha even has something close to a plot: it illustrates Mohandas Gandhi’s awakening to the power of non-violent resistance through a series of impressionistic, non-chronological vignettes. If it is still a long way from conventional opera, its extraordinary meditative passages offer a tremendous gift to any director interested in exploring the intersection of abstract ritual and narrative drama.
The new production at the Komische Oper – a co-production with the Theater Basel, where it had its première in May of this year – couldn’t quite find that elusive balance. Directed by choreographer Sidi Larbi Cherkaoui and featuring dancers from the Eastman company alongside its ensemble of singers, this Satyagraha was an uneven blend of fascinating ideas, a few stunning images, and extended passages that seemed perfectly content to squander the majesty of Mr Glass’s score. As a work of dance it may well have been a great success – the audience seemed to love it – but as a unified piece of musical drama it proved oddly unsatisfying.
Mr Glass’s music lends itself well to dance; around the time of Satyagraha he was also writing a series of pieces for Lucinda Childs – whose choreographic contributions to Einstein were little short of miraculous – and he has worked with other choreographers in the decades since. The problem with this production was not that it focused on the dance elements at the expense of the drama, but that the dance seemed intent on pursuing its own highly individual aesthetic with little regard for the music it was supposed to accompany. During some of the most vigorous dance sequences one suspected that, had the orchestra started to play ‘Tales from the Vienna Woods’ or ‘East St. Louis Toodle-Oo’, it would not have made much difference.
This gulf between music and movement was most apparent in the deeply frustrating third act. It opened with the promising image of several figures walking along a spiralling path while carrying handfuls of paint which dripped from their hands, marking their progress on the floor of the tilted stage; it was precisely the kind of slow, meticulous, almost hypnotic scene that the music demanded, and it came as a welcome respite after the constant exertions of the first two acts. Then the dancers were let loose, breaking the spell of the moment. It may have been very liberating to cavort with such abandon on a floor covered with wet paint, but it sat awkwardly next to the meditative mood of Mr Glass’s music and the theme of the opera in general.
In the production’s best moments, it actually did manage to fuse movement and light into a visual spectacle that not only complemented the music, but conveyed the emotional essence of Gandhi’s struggle. The opening scene of the second act, in which the white-robed Gandhi was hounded by an amorphous cluster of black-clad assailants, was wholly magnificent, and even the fervent procession of passport burners later in the same act generated its own particular energy. But these moments of inspiration served mostly to highlight the scenes in which an excess of physical movement was deployed merely for its own sake. Mr Cherkaoui is, even to the untrained observer, obviously a choreographer of considerable talent and it seems probable that anyone approaching this production from a dance background would come away with a very different impression. But Satyagraha is, in the end, an opera, and must also be held accountable to the expectations of an opera viewer.
At its most focussed, the production offered a vision of Gandhi as an individual surrounded by the powerful, sometimes dangerous might of the crowd. It was far less interested in the supporting characters and did very little to establish them as forces within the drama. Even for those familiar with the opera, it was often difficult to figure out who was who and, in the busiest scenes, who was actually singing. Cathrin Lange had comparatively little stage time, but was superb whenever she was present, lifting graceful high notes above the wonderful ensemble at the centre of the second act. Mirka Wagner and Karolina Gumos provided the second scene of the first act with its elegant refrain, and gave the opening of the third act a haunting calm. Tom Eric Lie’s warm voice was a cornerstone of the Indian Opinion scene, and Tomasz Wija’s declamatory edge was ideally suited to the final scene of the first act.
At the centre of the evening was Stefan Cifolelli, whose remarkable Gandhi was as much a physical endurance test as a vocal performance. If he seemed a touch underpowered in the opening scene and some of the ensembles – although most of the singers struggled to make themselves heard over the thunder of what turned out to be a very loud stage – his ability to maintain any kind of poise while being shoved back and forth and turned on his head by the mob, let alone craft calm, rounded, intensely melodic vocal lines, was little short of extraordinary. Yet Mr Cifolelli had an unflappable demeanour that gave the production its centre of gravity; and by the end of the evening he still had enough energy left to intone the words of the closing scene with no small amount of purity and dignity.
There were a few moments early in the opera where the choir didn’t seem wholly in sync with the orchestra, but they were minor; and when they were locked into the rhythms of the score they were an impressive force, perhaps nowhere more so than the opening of the second act. Jonathan Stockhammer, presiding over the strings and woodwinds of the Komische Oper orchestra, managed to craft an idiomatically Glassian sound without seeming overly indebted to the textures and tempi of the composer-approved studio recording. His rhythmic flexibility and ability to find drama within the superstructure of each scene resulted in many thrilling moments in the first two acts. Yet it was the third act that stood as the evening’s greatest musical accomplishment: Mr Stockhammer’s patience and focus created a dream-like intensity that almost single-handedly elevated the conclusion out of the physical realm of the opening acts into a spiritual world of ideals.
Satyagraha is very much an opera for our time; its oblique treatment of crowds and individuals, and its message of action through non-violence seem no less relevant now than they were in 1980 when the opera had its first performances. Yet despite its skilful assembly and handful of striking images, the new production at the Komische Oper offered only glimpses of the opera’s rocky path toward enlightenment. The vocal performances and the orchestra’s fluid approach to Mr Glass’s score, however, were sufficient to invest the evening with its own particular magic.



Comentarios