Alemania
Defiance
Bernard Haitink’s most recent appearances with the Berlin Philharmonic have inclined towards works associated with the final years of a composer’s life: Bruckner’s Ninth, Schubert’s unfinished B minor symphony and Mahler’s Das Lied von der Erde have all received grandly scaled, nobly elegiac performances under his guidance. For his most recent appearance, he turned his attention to perhaps the greatest valedictory symphony of all, Mahler’s Ninth. Mahler had been obsessed with death – the death of children, the death that precedes resurrection, the death that comes with the hammer blows of fate – throughout his career, but by the end of the twentieth century’s first decade he may have sensed it drawing closer. His premonitions turned out to be correct: he died only a year after completing the Ninth, leaving the sketches for a tenth symphony largely unorchestrated. This uncanny foresight, perhaps no more than coincidence, has led many conductors to approach the Ninth as a work of almost mystical profundity existing at the very boundary separating earthly life from whatever lies beyond.
Mr Haitink, who has been conducting the symphony for half a century and whose 1970 recording is regarded by many as a classic, seemed to have little time for such fanciful ideas. In the course of the evening he re-framed it as a monumental struggle with fate, a work of rage and uncertainty belonging not to some imagined afterlife, but to our own corporeal existence. The Berlin Philharmonic, whose unfailingly elegant playing was sometimes pushed to extremes of hushed slowness, gave Mr Haitink’s extraordinary vision an immediacy that only a handful of orchestras in the world would have been able to match. The result was a thrilling, emotionally draining and wholly unforgettable triumph of a performance.
The symphony began at a point of relative calm: soft strings, a restrained chiming from the harp, and a mellow solo horn floating just above it all. This deceptive tranquillity, however, did not last. Although Mr Haitink began at a deliberate pace and kept the tempi slow and majestic throughout, the movement soon established a penchant for fierce and fiery declamation. At its most volatile it suggested less a work for full orchestra than a confrontation between the different sections. The brass, and especially the trumpets, played with a force and volume that sounded initially undisciplined, although it soon became apparent that this was part of Mr Haitink’s vision: the trumpets weren’t playing with the strings so much as against them.
The horns, at their weightiest, were jarring and fearful, and the muted trombones sounded wonderfully alien, less a textural effect than a subtle intrusion. It was clear that Mr Haitink was not interested in softening the sometimes blunt intensity of Mahler’s score, and yet the intervals between maelstroms could yield moments of considerable beauty: the trembling strings beneath the harp arpeggios mid-way through the movement and the brief woodwind dialogue near the very end were both exquisite. Mr Haitink’s greatest skill, however, was his ability to free the movement from any sense of conventional time. The familiar contours of the music were stretched into a vast, forbidding – yet still strangely recognisable – landscape in which, but for Mr Haitink’s patient direction, it would have been all too easy to get lost.
In the opening of the second movement, the orchestra bore down on the Ländler rhythm with a notable heaviness. The tempo was, again, on the slow side, but it was less the pace than the relentless accentuation that gave the movement its unusual lilt. The basses and cellos attacked with unvarnished earthiness and the woodwinds answered with exuberance. The abrupt shift into the waltz-like second section maintained the steady pace, but increased the frenzied rhythmic drive, going from joyous stomp to intoxicated lurch. Then, close to the end of the movement, Mr Haitink pulled everything together into a lightly-sprung dance, just to underline that the laboured heaviness of the first part had indeed been intentional. In the delicate woodwind exclamations of the final bars, there was an almost surprising economy of expression.
Even by the standards of the evening, the third movement opened at a high level of intensity, with prominent brass and vigorous strings preparing once again for confrontation. Mr Haitink pushed the music forward with a sustained ferocity that had appeared only in passing during the opening movements. And yet, in the central section there was a fleeting moment of calm that brought us back to the very beginning of the evening. It was, however, short-lived: the agitation of the full orchestra returned with even greater force bringing the movement to an imposing conclusion.
The qualities that had defined the performance during the first three movements – the heavily accented rhythms, the mighty heft of the brass, and the uneasy sense of opposition between the various sections – began to change during the fourth. The strings produced a lustrous, almost conventionally beautiful sound in the opening bars, and had reasserted themselves as the central force by the time the rest of the instruments started to join in. The trumpets and horns seemed content to accentuate rather than dominate, and the woodwinds added richness to the movement’s gradual build. With the orchestra in complete alignment, Mr Haitink was able to sculpt a climax that was both unerringly grand and gratifyingly simple. The symphony didn’t so much come to an end as fade beyond the limit of human audibility; if the violins had been forced to play any quieter they would have made no sound at all. Yet the effect was completely breathtaking. After nearly ninety minutes of defiant struggle, the symphony arrived at a moment of serenity that was all the more arresting for being so hard-won.
Comentarios