Alemania

The Redeemer Reconsidered

Jesse Simon
Tcherniakov: Parsifal
Tcherniakov: Parsifal © Ruth Walz, 2018
Berlin, lunes, 2 de abril de 2018.
Staatsoper Unter den Linden. Wagner: Parsifal. Dmitri Tcherniakov, director. Lauri Vasar (Amfortas), René Pape (Gurnemanz), Andreas Schager (Parsifal), Falk Struckmann (Klingsor), Nina Stemme (Kundry), Reinhard Hagen (Titurel), Jun-Sang Han, Dominic Barberi (Grail Knights), Sonia Grané, Natalia Skrycka, Florian Hoffmann, Linard Vrielink (Squires), Elsa Dreisig, Adriane Queiroz, Anja Schlosser, Sónia Grané, Narine Yeghiyan, Natalia Skrycka (Flower Maidens), Natalia Skrycka (Voice from Above). Staatskapelle Berlin. Daniel Barenboim, conductor
0,0004677

When Dmitri Tcherniakov’s production of Parsifal opened in 2015, it was greeted with outrage and adulation in roughly equal measure. Three years later, it has established itself as a fixture of the Staatsoper’s Festtage, and a reliable highlight of the Easter season in Berlin. The staging itself has grown no less unsettling in the intervening years; with each viewing, one comes away with an ever-greater appreciation of the degree to which Mr Tcherniakov has confronted the most problematic aspects of what may be Wagner’s most thematically thorny opera. But for its first outing in the recently refurbished house on Unter den Linden, the Staatskapelle and a first rate cast under the direction of Daniel Barenboim delivered the kind of intensely majestic performance that one must consider themselves fortunate to have experienced at least once in their lives. 

In Parsifal, Wagner created a self-contained world of arcane ritual that retains only glancing similarities with the moral edification found in Wolfram von Eschenbach and Chrétien de Troyes. It is easy to approach the opera as a fable of redemption (in a specifically Christian sense) and many traditional productions will adhere strictly to this narrow interpretation. Yet there is too much else going on in the libretto for such a reading to be entirely convincing. Mr Tcherniakov has not set out to be provocative or to turn Parsifal into something it is not, but he has not been afraid to ask difficult questions of the opera and present his findings for our consideration.

What Mr Tcherniakov has discovered behind the noble veneer of sacred ritual is a closed brotherhood driven to madness by the myth of purity, a world in which women are unwelcome due to a consuming fear that they might somehow expose the latent impurities that the men have been unable to excise from themselves; he has found a deranged cult of personality surrounding Titurel, and one of the most brutal father/son relationships ever committed to the stage; he has discovered a love story perhaps more tragic than Tristan und Isolde, in which the lovers (Amfortas and Kundry) are hounded and tortured for their sin of passion; most importantly, Mr Tcherniakov has seen through the supposed heroism of the title character, who earns his membership in the boy’s club of purity by discovering his own revulsion toward the feminine.  

Mr Tcherniakov’s singular determination to expose the perversities of the opera did not, however, prevent him from creating a tightly structured, dramatically cohesive work of theatre. The opening scenes, set in a dingy octagonal room that may have been a chapel in a past life, conveyed the loneliness and isolation at the heart of the grail kingdom and suggested a futility beneath the meaningless rituals observed by a group of knights and squires who had long since forgotten what it was all supposed to mean. With the arrival of Kundry came an unease that the men were able to confront only through threats and empty posturing; and there was nothing holy or beautiful about the end of the first act, in which Amfortas is bullied, bled then cast aside as the followers of Titurel clamour for blood.

Only the beginning and end of the second act seemed perplexing. Klingsor, characterised as a kindly old patriarch living with dozens of apparently motherless daughters, seemed incapable of the villainy ascribed to him by Gurnemanz. Yet the central scene, in which Parsifal has a flashback to his abortive sexual awakening (rudely interrupted by his mother), only to discover a life-changing horror in the body of Kundry, remains so completely compelling that it changes one’s understanding of the scene forever. The first part of the third act almost strikes a conciliatory tone until it becomes clear that Parsifal’s resistance to Kundry has infected him with messianic delusions. Instead of redemption, Mr Tcherniakov ends the opera with a tableau of writhing ugliness, a sea of aimless believers with arms extended in mass delirium, and Gurnemanz committing one unforgettably shocking act in the opera’s final seconds. 

Musically the evening was in a class by itself, superior even to the previous Festtage performances. The Staatskapelle had reached a state of grace even before the curtain had gone up, with fulsome strings and subtle woodwinds giving way to tidal swells of brass. Daniel Barenboim has always been good at drawing mysterious solemnity from the Vorspiel, but on this evening he achieved something close to perfection. The intensity of those opening moments in the dark of the theatre carried over into the first act, bringing momentum to the action without compromising the spacious tempi and ineffable majesty at the heart of Mr Barenboim’s reading. Gurnemanz’s journey through the backstory proceeded with unerring focus, and his lament for the dead swan was bolstered by a sad luminescence.

The arrival of the knights at the grail hall was suitably grand with huge timpani, ringing horns and chiming bells. Only a few moments of brass fatigue near the end – and some prodigious feats of coughing from an unusually ill audience – prevented the first act from being flawless. Nor did the orchestra seem to tire as the evening went on. The arrival of the flower-maidens was matched with gauzy delicacy, but with the arrival of Kundry the orchestra locked into a long, slow ascent toward the culminating battle of wills. Even in the third act, they had enough energy to craft an achingly gloomy Vorspiel, a majestic evocation of the magic of Good Friday, and a terrifying showdown between Amfortas the grail knights.

The much-publicised new acoustic of the Staatsoper has, in many of this season’s productions, tended to favour the orchestra which, at its loudest, can create a wall of sound through which only the most strident voices can pass. This proved to be less of a problem on this evening, due largely to a core group of mighty performances from René Pape, Nina Stemme and Andreas Schager. Mr Pape, in particular, reached into the audience with seemingly little effort, crafting long, clean, commanding lines rippling with dramatic nuance. In conveying the nearly impossible balance of piousness, despair, passion, humility and hope that exists within Gurnemanz, Mr Pape has few equals. 

Andreas Schager was already a great Parsifal when the production first appeared, but his command of the role seems to have deepened in the intervening years. On this evening his willingness to underplay Parsifal’s first appearance in the grail kingdom – to tone down the raw power while retaining the brash, clueless arrogance – paid great dividends in the second act: his ‘moral awakening’ at the hands of Kundry filled the room with a sudden, jarring clarity and a terror impossible to ignore. The vocal intensity unleashed in that moment transformed an already excellent second act into something considerably greater.

If Nina Stemme did not seem as fully engaged with the physical demands of the staging, her vocal conception of Kundry was arresting both for its focus and emotional range. She sounded harried in her first appearance, dealing with the abuse of the squires with burned-out resignation; even in her scene with Klingsor there was an edge of exhaustion to her taunting words. Yet the Kundry who appeared before Parsifal moments later, speaking his name for the first time, sang with an unconcealed beauty that was all the more captivating for being so unexpected. But even her most gorgeous moments were shaded with an edge of anxiety, and the increasingly frantic desperation that crept in during the course of the second act was perhaps the evening’s greatest feat of vocal acting.

Lauri Vasar sang a noble, elegant Amfortas, although his robust tone and smooth phrasing made him sound perhaps a touch too healthy during his first appearance; yet he was wholly convincing railing against the grail and his father in the third act. As Klingsor, Falk Struckmann managed to sound exactly like the unexpectedly benign figure on stage – scattered, eccentric and slightly sinister – with no sacrifice of vocal presence. The choir, too, were on superb form throughout the evening; during the grail ritual, the women, hidden somewhere high in the auditorium, sounded genuinely mysterious and otherworldly.

Mr Tcherniakov’s vision of Parsifal may not qualify as traditional Eastertide entertainment, but that is perhaps no bad thing. Instead of losing its way in the pomp of ritual, his staging offers a taut character drama that makes light work of the opera’s long running time; and while its conclusions may prove distressing for anyone still clinging to the myth of redemption, it nonetheless leaves one with the sense of having witnessed something profound. Between the staging and the exceptional standard of the cast and orchestra, the evening was nothing less than the transformative experience Wagner intended Parsifal to be.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.