Alemania

Fate Unchallenged

Jesse Simon
Plácido Domingo y Anna Netrebko
Plácido Domingo y Anna Netrebko © 2018 by Monika Rittershaus
Berlin, domingo, 17 de junio de 2018.
Staatsoper Unter den Linden. Verdi: Macbeth. Harry Kupfer, director. Plácido Domingo (Macbeth). Anna Netrebko (Lady Macbeth). Kwangchul Youn (Banquo). Fabio Sartori (Macduff). Evelin Novak (Lady in waiting). Florian Hoffmann (Malcolm). Dominic Barberi (Doctor). Jan Martiník (Assassin). Insoo Hwoang (Servant). Raphael Küster, Niels Domdey (Apparitions). Chorus and Orchestra of the Staatsoper Berlin. Daniel Barenboim, conductor. .
0,0003395

At first glance, the Staatsoper’s new Macbeth seemed something of a throwback. Harry Kupfer’s unwillingness to stray too far from the libretto or overstuff his staging with tenuously connected ideas was almost defiantly at odds with the ostentatiously clever, concept-driven readings that are currently the norm; visually, the monochromatic sets and nocturnal mood would not have looked out of place in any of his celebrated productions from the nineties. Yet if it seemed cautious and even a touch conservative, it was also remarkably satisfying, a simple rendering of a familiar tale that was often content to cede the spotlight to the voices and personalities – primarily Anna Netrebko and Plácido Domingo – who gave the evening its claim to greatness.

From the moment the curtain rose – or rather fell – to reveal a war-ravaged landscape and distant fires rising toward an ominous cloud of black smoke, it was clear we were in Mr Kupfer’s world. The action unfolded against a series of dark textural surfaces that caught the pale, cool, offstage light in myriad ways. The hall of Macbeth’s castle was elegant and almost oppressively minimal, its dark walls and floors offset by a spotless white leather sofa. Banquo’s murder took place in an abandoned building site near an airport – and there can be no more appropriate location for a Berlin production than an airport building site – dominated by the giant claw of an excavator. The scenes were set with pin-sharp HD back projections, ‘enhanced’ with some questionable CGI flames and lightning that constituted the production’s only real visual weakness.

The succession of dark spaces was populated by figures in crisp military dress uniform who served primarily to underline the proximity of luxury and wartime horror. Many directors would have been more emphatic in drawing the connection, but for Mr Kupfer it was simply another addition to the texture. Indeed Mr Kupfer seemed less interested in making bold statements than in creating a space in which the vocal performances could flourish. Yet, unlike his recent Fidelio, also for the Staatsoper, his muted sensibility rarely came across as indifference. The direction was focussed throughout, neither losing sight of its intentions nor sacrificing them to indulgent caprice; the larger ensembles were unfussy, while the intimate interactions of Macbeth and Lady Macbeth were suffused with an acceptance of the inevitable.

It was the singers who gave the evening its sense of occasion. Plácido Domingo has performed the title role in Berlin twice before – in revivals of the Peter Mussbach production – yet in his earliest appearances he still seemed to be exploring the character. He was oddly anxious in his first meeting with the witches, conveying considerably less assurance than Kwangchul Youn’s sturdy, quietly commanding Banquo. And there was little evidence of ambition in his subsequent scene with Lady Macbeth; he seemed content to follow her plan, already resigned to his fate. These scenes were accompanied by a vocal presence that came dangerously close to undistinguished, a touch drawn in the lower notes and unemphatic in the higher outbursts. Yet the performance gathered in intensity as it went, culminating in a final scene in which nuanced phrasing, emotive power and stage charisma locked suddenly into perfect alignment. When he sang of life leaving his body it was the most energised he had sounded all evening, and the aria that followed emerged as the perfect distillation of a lifetime immersed in Verdian drama. The decision to end the opera with the original death scene from the 1847 version gave Mr Domingo the last word and provided a gloomy production with an appropriately bitter conclusion.

If Mr Domingo spent the opera entangled in the tragedy of his character, Anna Netrebko’s force of personality all but eclipsed the figure of Lady Macbeth. It was a magnificent performance full of shimmering high notes, melodic phrasing, unfailingly elegant dynamics, and an ability to position her own voice just slightly above the ensembles; it also remained slightly aloof from the production, as though she had been tasked with incorporating a programme of Verdi arias into the staged action. This is not to say she was unconvincing pushing Mr Domingo around the stage or trying to keep the banquet together in the face of Macbeth’s madness, but that the extraordinary qualities of her performance were most in evidence when she was allowed to command the stage without the burden of narrative distraction. Thus the drinking song, which required greater engagement with the surrounding scene, was less exciting than ‘Vieni, t’affreta’ or the sleepwalking scene, which were captivating through vocal command alone.

Ms Netrebko and Mr Domingo may have been the evening’s big draws, but Fabio Sartori was an impressive Macduff, making his presence felt in the ensembles, and rising to great heights during his lyrical ‘Ah, la paterna mano’; and Kwangchul Youn sang a sympathetic Banquo, retaining his essential nobility even in the face of death. Only the chorus of witches, who swarmed onto the stage in the first scene to divest the dead soldiers of their valuables, sounded less secure; there were several moments that called for greater rhythmic agility and a more incisive attack, and a few instances where they seemed slightly adrift from the orchestra. Daniel Barenboim’s grandly-scaled approach to the score, however, was perfectly matched to the staging. The ensemble scenes at the end of the first two acts unfolded with thrilling immediacy, the aftermath of Duncan’s murder revelled in its ominous mood, and even the gentler arias were attentive and rich with portent.

It may be that the presence of high profile singers – or the knowledge that it would be filmed for a DVD release – caused the production to remain so firmly on the safe side. For all the violence in the story and the passion in Verdi’s music, there was something meticulously tasteful about the sets, the costumes, the singing and the direction, suggesting that very little had been left to chance; in the muted palette of the staging, the messy red of human blood had been excluded almost entirely. Yet if there were few risks, there were also few disappointments; perhaps the gravity of the music and the presence of the principals was ultimately enough to sustain the evening.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.