Alemania

Musikfest 2: Contemplating a Monument

Jesse Simon
Musikfest 2: Contemplating a Monument
Berlin, jueves, 6 de septiembre de 2018.
Philharmonie. Mahler: Symphony No. 3 in D minor. Susan Graham, alto. GewandhausChor and Kinderchor. Boston Symphony Orchestra. Andris Nelsons, conductor. Berlin Musikfest 2018
0,0001171

In the past three or four years, Andris Nelsons has been responsible for some of the most memorable Mahler performances in Berlin. If none of his readings have been wholly without their excesses of interpretation, his level of energy, lack of superficiality, and commitment to exploring the depths of Mahler’s monumental scores often yields unexpected insights. As part of this year’s Musikfest, Mr Nelsons led the Boston Symphony Orchestra through a Third symphony that was arguably his most consistent and balanced Mahler performance to date. Where his Fifth seemed episodic and his Sixth at times overly ambitious, the Third was given a broadly paced, clear-sighted reading that made sense of sprawl without sacrificing the dramatic intensity of its individual moments. 

The first movement was the most perfectly realised. After the opening statement from the brass had subsided, the first section began to move forward at a speed no faster than a crawl; the taut playing from the trumpets, trombones and low strings suggested a forbidding vastness full of innumerable unseen terrors. Mr Nelsons rarely missed an opportunity to highlight the sudden outbursts and percussive intrusions that posed a constant threat to the ominous stillness. Nor did he allow us to forget the bass drum. He lingered over the interstitial passages separating the sections, in which a faint drum-beat is the only audible sound – in many ways his attention to the movement’s capacity for near-silence was just as impressive as his treatment of the wild full-orchestra passages – but even in the most emphatic moments, the bass drum emerged as both a constant presence and a driving force. 

If the tempi of the different sections were reasonably slow, the movement as a whole felt remarkably concise. There was considerable attention given to shaping the individual episodes, and it was difficult not to be swept up in the heady momentum of the march, or lost in the beautifully rendered trombone lament of the subsequent section; yet Mr Nelsons presided over the movement with such an assured command of its structure that nothing was ever allowed to drift too far from the central thread. When the pace picked up going into the climactic final section, it felt wholly unforced, and offered a vigorous conclusion to a superbly considered and wonderfully played half hour of music. 

If the rest of the symphony never quite reached the same heights, it was certainly not without its extraordinary moments. The second movement was fleet and delicate with detailed woodwinds and elegant violins. Mr Nelsons was able to create a subtle agitation, even in the placid outer sections, through minor but frequent adjustments in tempo; yet the orchestra were so responsive to his direction the one was aware of the effect far more than the means of achieving it. The third movement was perfectly paced, alternating effortlessly between restlessness and the tranquillity of the posthorn interludes (which, alas, had a few wobbly notes). While the individual groups were, for the most part, magnificent – the hushed violins were astonishing, the trombones polished, and the percussionists close to faultless – there were moments when the full orchestra could sound unbalanced and a touch unruly, overburdened by the weight of the brass. The hauntingly tranquil mood of the fourth movement provided an appealing foundation for Susan Graham’s gentle, introspective reading of the Nietzsche setting; and while the women and children of the Gewandhaus choir had the most prominent part in the fifth, it was the low strings and percussionists who stood at the heart of the movement. 

The opening of the sixth movement contained the evening’s most beautiful playing. The rapt concentration from the strings produced a captivatingly rich sound, and Mr Nelsons ensured that the principal theme passed from section to section with assurance and ease. Only in the loudest moments did one again have a sense of imbalance: the strings were able to establish a tenuous co-existence with the trombones, but the addition of the horn section tipped the scales. Yet Mr Nelsons was largely able to hold the movement’s capacity for overwhelming expression in check; indeed, for a conductor who so often pushes the orchestra to the limits of safety in search of ecstatic moments, the restraint displayed in the final bars of the symphony was unexpected. If the finale did not strive to overpower, there was a certain satisfaction to be found in its equanimity. 

Mr Nelsons is often an energetic presence on the podium, but in his reading of Mahler’s Third that natural excitability was tempered by a notably heightened confidence. His ability to articulate the drama in the work’s key moments was never in doubt, but the occasional tendency to overreach and overstate in his quest to realise those moments was almost nowhere to be found. Despite its few brief passages of orchestral imbalance, the performance that emerged on this evening was a model of control and assured judgement. Fortunately Berlin audiences will not have to wait quite so long for the next instalment in Mr Nelsons’ survey of the Mahler symphonies: he is scheduled to conduct the mighty Second symphony in December. 

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.