Alemania

Musikfest 3: Parallels

Jesse Simon
François-Xavier Roth
François-Xavier Roth © Holger Talinski
Berlin, viernes, 14 de septiembre de 2018.
Philharmonie. Stravinsky: Symphonies d’instruments à vent. Zimmermann: Concerto for Violin and Large Orchestra. Debussy: Gigues (from Images pour orchestre). Ligeti: Lontano. Debussy: Rondes de Printemps (from Images pour orchestre). Ligeti: Atmosphères. Debussy: Ibéria (from Images pour orchestre). Carolin Widmann, violin. Berlin Philharmonic. François-Xavier Roth, conductor
0,0002349

As a conductor, François-Xavier Roth has established himself as a champion of twentieth and twenty-first century music, an intelligent, observant interpreter whose readings are rarely beholden to tradition; part of what makes him such a persuasive ambassador for the modern repertoire is his knack for creating an intriguing concert programme. For his guest appearance at this year’s Musikfest, he led the Berlin Philharmonic through an evening assembled from sources as diverse as Debussy, Stravinsky, Zimmermann and Ligeti. If there was no obvious conceptual thread tying the pieces together, the mere proximity of these distinct voices made for an evening rich in sonic cross-reference and unexpected affinities.

Even Stravinsky’s brief, agreeable Symphonies of Wind Instruments, which served as an overture to the evening, offered some hints as to what would follow. In the elegant, free-flowing flute lines one could hear echoes of Debussy (the work is dedicated to his memory), and the static pools of low-end sound generated by the trombones and tuba offered brief flashes of the tonal concentration that Ligeti would achieve in Lontano. Mr Roth did not belabour the point: his reading was unhurried but economical, exploring the sonic possibilities arising from the various combinations of wind instruments while retaining the essential motility of the piece.

The genial inventions of Stravinsky offered a stark contrast to Zimmermann’s Violin Concerto. Between Carolin Widmann’s fierce realisation of the solo part and Mr Roth’s tightly focussed rhythmic sensibility, the concerto seemed less a performance than a blunt-yet-effective argument in favour of a neglected work. It opened with impressive force: the dense sound and wiry momentum of the orchestra provided an engagingly turbulent setting for a violin part that seemed less interested in showy virtuosity than in direct attacks on small, striking phrases.

However it was during the second movement, a deeply felt expression of anguish, that the nature of the piece came into sharper focus. Ms Widmann’s playing had no obvious technical flaws, but the tone she adopted was impassioned and unsparing. There were moments of conventional beauty – in one passage she drew elongated trills from her instrument, accompanied only by the haunting sound of the celesta and bass drum – but the movement contained too much suffering for the violin to escape unscathed. Instead, Ms Widmann embraced the movement’s pervasive anxiety with an almost unnerving directness. The darkness subsided somewhat during the third movement which introduced some jazzier rhythms on its way to a bracing finale, but the unease did not disappear entirely. The whole concerto lasted only around twenty minutes, but the performance packed a considerable range of emotional experience into its reasonably brief duration.

On paper, the programme of the second half looked especially intriguing. It featured Debussy’s much-loved and oft-performed Images pour orchestre, but instead of playing it in sequence Mr Roth isolated the individual movements by interleaving Lontano and Atmosphères, Ligeti’s two orchestral masterpieces from the sixties. There was an odd yet undeniable justice to the pairing: the mere presence of Ligeti forced one to listen to Images in a different way, although Mr Roth’s readings, which went out of their way to highlight the moments of consonance, removed some of the guess-work. The emergence of ‘Gigues’ from a cloud of quiet high notes certainly looked forward to Lontano even if, for Debussy, it was more an effect than an end unto itself. Mr Roth offered plenty of attention to detail in the string parts and was able to summon a weighty sound from the full orchestra, but there was also a touch of heaviness in the way the gigue theme unfolded and even a few moments that seemed largely indifferent to the separation of melody and texture.

Lontano, however, was captivating. Like the preceding piece, it came into being from a cluster of high-pitched sound, but soon followed a very different path. The fascination with texture that Mr Roth displayed in the first part of Images was perfectly matched to Ligeti’s timbral explorations, and the orchestra responded with some of the finest playing of the evening, from the strange overtones of the flutes to the alien sound of the contrabass clarinet to the breathtaking hush of the violins and basses. If Mr Roth was less interested in the work’s capacity for stasis than its penchant for juxtaposition, his reading nonetheless captured its time-stretching, perception-altering majesty.

The long slow fade of Lontano’s final moments offered a perfect introduction to ‘Rondes de Printemps’, which seemed to open with an echo of the previous work’s fluttering strings. Yet the performance, like ‘Gigues’ before it, demanded greater suppleness of rhythm and more delicate delineation of form. Atmosphères, however, came close to the same level as the earlier Ligeti performance. Although the orchestra was right in front of us, one couldn’t always tell where exactly the strange sounds were coming from, and it is that sense of disorientation that makes the piece so endlessly rewarding. Mr Roth again drew great playing from the various sections of the orchestra: the formless thunder of the basses that followed the high piccolos was one of the most arresting sounds to emerge from the stage all evening.

‘Ibéria’, while still erring on the side of heavy, was perhaps the most successful of the three Images. The accents were bold and the castanets surprisingly imposing in the first section, although the second section remained at a slight distance from the mood of nocturnal stillness that can make it so enveloping; but the final section with its violins played like guitars and its distant rumble of basses (recalling Atmosphères) had an energetic pace and undeniable enthusiasm. Images, of course, is always a pleasure to hear, but on this evening it was the unfeigned anguish of Zimmermann and the sublime sonic landscapes of Ligeti that left the greatest impression.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.