Alemania
Art and Entertainment
The Semperoper’s new production of Ariadne auf Naxos was, above all, a triumph of musicianship. While David Hermann’s staging found a satisfying balance between the dynamic comedy of the prologue and the ambitious conceptual arrangement of the opera-proper, it was the luxurious sound of the Sächsiche Staatskapelle, the strong ensemble cast – highlighted by Daniela Sindram’s magnificent Komponist and Daniela Fally’s effervescent Zerbinetta – and the detailed, idiomatic musical direction of Christian Thielemann that located the emotional grandeur beneath the genial surfaces of what may be Strauss’ most approachable operatic work.
The foundation for the staging was established even before the curtain had gone up. At the centre of the large gallery on the first floor of the Semperoper was a dining table on a slightly raised platform where a group of six well-dressed individuals appeared to be in the middle of a dinner party; they looked so at home in their opulent surroundings that it took a moment to realise they were all moving at half speed. Next to them, a trio of string players played a series of refined divertimenti. Both the musicians and the dining party attracted considerable attention from the evening’s audience, who stood around snapping pictures on their phones. It was a nice aperitif – who doesn’t enjoy a bonus programme of string trios with their pre-opera drink – but it also doubled as a reminder of the unseen figure for whom the opera within the opera was written.
Soon the audience left for their seats and the opera began. For the prologue, Mr Hermann was able to draw out the sly wit in von Hofmannsthal’s libretto simply by playing everything as straight as possible. Instead of cluttering his staging with sight-gags and slapstick, he placed a collection of well-observed characters in a confined space and let the comedy take care of itself. What emerged was both very funny and remarkably unforced, a series of escalating conflicts made all the more ridiculous by the single-mindedness which every character seemed unable to shake. The set was minimal, a nondescript white wall with three doors, placed very close to the front of the stage; what lay behind the doors, however, could change from moment to moment. The door which opened onto the Haushofmeister’s store of fireworks, opened again moments later to reveal the tenor’s dressing room. Yet even this simple device was neither overplayed nor used solely for comedic effect: in the prologue’s finest scene, the composer and Zerbinetta appeared and disappeared through different doors, spiralling in on one another but never quite meeting.
Mr Hermann attempted to do considerably more with the opera-proper and his efforts were mostly successful. The set was divided into two roughly equal halves, a colourful woodland glade for the commedia players and a dark, half-destroyed ruin of a palace for Ariadne. Only Zerbinetta seemed able to cross from one side to the other without trepidation. For the first half, the action followed a predictable course, with Ariadne and the comedians locked in an uneasy coexistence. After Zerbinetta’s song, however, the commedia players set to wooing Naiad, Dryad and Echo who crossed reluctantly to the pastoral side. The potential rapprochement was interrupted by the arrival of Circe, who transformed the comedians into pigs and caused the set to split in two. The set receded into darkness while Bacchus and Ariadne shared their climactic scene on the empty stage; when the set returned, the characters from both prologue and opera were strewn about as if victims of a massacre. But as the music gathered in intensity, they began to stir and come back to life.
Then the dinner party guests came in and ruined everything, posing for pictures and attempting to take selfies with the opera singers. Instead of the great reconciliation between comedy and tragedy, we were left with the gloomy sensation of money poisoning art. On the one hand it was hard not to approve of such a scathing critique of the culture that has turned everyone with a mobile phone into the worst kind of tourist – and one certainly hopes that everyone in the audience who spent the early part of the evening turning the bourgeois dinner party into an Instagram story felt thoroughly shamed – yet it allowed what had been an otherwise extraordinary evening to end on a note of disappointment.
Once the feeling had subsided, it was mostly the memory of the evening’s great performances that remained. Foremost among them was Daniela Sindram’s composer. It is easy to play the character as an impetuous youth trying and failing to maintain illusions of aesthetic purity in the face of practical compromise, but Ms Sindram achieved something considerably greater: she burrowed through the pretentions and affectations to reveal the plight of a serious artist crushed beneath a steady accumulation of disappointments. In her reaction to the Haushofmeister’s decree and her tentative opening up to Zerbinetta there was a private tragedy as intense and affecting as Ariadne’s. Ms Sindram was able to integrate this nuance and depth of character into a vocal performance both subtle and soaring, rarely drawing attention to itself but quietly outshining everything around it.
If Daniela Fally’s Zerbinetta was not as rich a dramatic creation – even in her scene with the composer she remained all surface – the performance was wholly enchanting, weaving crisp articulation and vocal acrobatics into a confident, charismatic physical performance. As Ariadne, Krassimira Stoyanova’s two arias at the beginning of the opera revealed impressive range and tonal depth, but there were also passages where purity of tone took precedence over clarity of text. ‘Es gibt ein Reich’ built to high notes of considerable beauty although the pace of the music – perhaps the only part of the evening that came across as rushed – robbed the scene of some of its intensity; her long scene with Bacchus, however, was rarely less than exquisite.
Stephen Gould had the ardent tone and vocal power necessary for Bacchus, but his manner seemed somehow detached from the rest of the production; his frustrated gestures and seeming inability to convey anything to the haunted Ariadne was undoubtedly the result of Mr Hermann’s vision for the character, but in vocal terms alone there was little to fault in Mr Gould’s bold pronouncements. The remainder of the cast was generally strong, with Albert Dohmen’s music master providing a grounding authority in the prologue, and the trio of Evelin Novak, Simone Schröder, Tuuli Takala (as Naiad, Dryad and Echo) conjuring dreamy harmonies at the sight of Bacchus’ ship.
At the centre of the evening was Christian Thielemann, whose ability to impose order on the drama while exploiting the full potential of Strauss’ dazzling orchestration was the production’s greatest asset. The overlapping situations and swift transitions of the prologue were rendered with remarkable precision and clarity; but when the action grew serious, as it did during the composer’s meeting with Zerbinetta, Mr Thielemann was able to coax a lucid ecstasy from the orchestra, heating up the music just enough that the vapours of irony burned away leaving only the raw glow of emotions. The opera-proper was a sustained offering of sparkling textures and elegant phrasing, culminating in a concluding scene that gathered steadily over the course of some twenty minutes towards a climax of overwhelming beauty.
As per the Haushofmeister’s instructions, the opera ended a few minutes before nine … and while it was not followed by some fireworks display in the traditional sense, the Semperoper made a nod to the implied ending of Ariadne by handing out sparklers at the door. The image of Theaterplatz illuminated by isolated showers of tiny sparks offered a fittingly magical conclusion to an evening in which comedy, drama and sublime music had enjoyed a fleeting but remarkable moment of unity.
Comentarios