Alemania

Pleasures and Guilty Pleasures

Jesse Simon
Pleasures and Guilty Pleasures
Berlin, viernes, 8 de marzo de 2019.
Philharmonie. Schönberg: Violin Concerto, op. 36. Tchaikovsky: Symphony No. 5 in E minor, op. 64. Patricia Kopatchinskaja, violin. Kirill Petrenko, conductor
0,000137

In some concert programmes, the interval can serve as a pause for breath between complementary pieces. On this evening it functioned more as a decisive boundary separating two very different halves. There was little on the surface to connect Patricia Kopatchinskaja’s transfixing performance of Schönberg’s Violin Concerto in the first part with Kirill Petrenko’s genial turn through Tchaikovsky’s much-loved Fifth Symphony in the second. Yet if the evening seemed more like two discrete half-concerts than a unified programme, the quality of the performances was sufficient to ensure that each half was satisfyingly memorable.

Schönberg’s Violin Concerto is no longer a rarity in the concert hall; the technical demands of the solo part have turned it into one of the central works which every up-and-coming violinist must confront. Yet there was nothing in Patricia Kopatchinskaja’s extraordinary performance that came across as familiar or routine. Her playing throughout occurred at such a high level of intensity and unfolded with such unshakeable focus that one was left not only with the sensation of encountering this music as if for the first time, but of being drawn into the intricacies of Schönberg’s world by the most fearless and trustworthy of guides.

Ms Kopatchinskaja possesses consummate technical skill, and it was no surprise to hear her glide through the work’s most difficult passages – the rapidly alternating arco and pizzicato, the high-wire act of the first movement cadenza, or the intensely rhythmic sections of the finale – with assurance, precision and grace. Yet even in the most forceful moments, there was never a sense that she was using virtuosity as a means of elevating her violin above the orchestra. If her performance was wholly captivating, it came about less through ostentatious gestures than through an irresistibly inward focus. She did not project the music into the auditorium, so much as pull us towards it.

If the sounds that emerged were notable for their subtlety, they were achieved through a reasonably unsubtle physical engagement with the music. Throughout the piece, Ms Kopatchinskaja lunged, wheeled and, even when not playing, conveyed the sense of being fully locked into the work’s secret rhythms. Far more than Mr Petrenko, who led the orchestra through a nicely balanced but largely deferential tour of the score, it was Ms Kopatchinskaja who gave the impression of driving the performance. She created the sense that everything coming from the orchestra was a consequence of the complex figures and simple exclamations originating in her violin.

As if giving an unforgettable performance of Schönberg’s concerto wasn’t enough, Ms Kopatchinskaja returned for one of the most charming encores in recent memory, pulling cellist Bruno Delepelaire forward for a performance of the second movement of Ravel’s Sonata for Violin and Cello that overflowed with rhythmic vitality. The chemistry between the two was apparent in the ease with which they traded rapid-fire pizzicato volleys back and forth, and their joyful exuberance proved infectious. Had the orchestra not eventually stood up to leave the stage, the applause might have gone on for considerably longer.

The popularity of Tchaikovsky’s Fifth Symphony, which formed the second half of the programme, seems to exist in an inverse relationship to its critical reception. It is easy to dismiss as an undemanding seat-filler. But a guilty pleasure is a source of pleasure all the same, and when given a performance of appropriate commitment and restraint, as Mr Petrenko did on this evening, it can transcend its (undeniable) capacity for overheated sentimentality and declare itself worthy of our admiration.

Mr Petrenko played the symphony just cool enough to make it engaging without robbing it of its sensuous delights. He took the slow opening of the first movement at a methodical, almost laboured pace that nonetheless highlighted the deep, rich sound of the massed strings. All hints of overt mannerism evaporated in the transition to the Allegro, which charged forth with exacting momentum and tightly coiled urgency. Mr Petrenko conveyed the sense of being in control of the movement’s every rise and fall, elaborating the themes without over-moulding them and generating considerable excitement along the way.

The second movement opened with a flawlessly-played solo horn floating just above the strings, and featured some stunning ensemble passages from the cellos. Mr Petrenko rarely held back when stating the movement’s achingly romantic central theme, but kept up just enough momentum to stop it from being saccharine. The climaxes were large and well-earned, and the quiet coda was played with an almost surprising nobility. The waltz movement was perhaps a touch too slow for dancing, but was shaped with an elegance that flirted with opulence only on occasion.

The symphony was not without its flaws. The trumpets and trombones were consistently too prominent, overshadowing some of the more interesting string passages in the first movement, and threatening to upset the fine balance achieved by the strings, winds and timpani in the second. Whether this was carelessness on Mr Petrenko’s part, or part of his vision for the piece, it was a jarring intrusion into an otherwise well-conceived performance. The fourth movement also suffered occasional moments when the different sections blended into an indifferently shaped whole, lacking the sharp definition of the earlier movements. Yet Mr Petrenko was able to lock everything back into focus for a suitably triumphant finale.

While the concert offered intriguing hints as to Mr Petrenko’s tenure with the Berlin Philharmonic might look like – he is due to take up his post as chief conductor in the coming season – it stopped short of providing concrete answers. The first half showed him to be a sympathetic accompanist, effectively ceding the performance to the soloist, while the second had undeniable moments of excitement. Yet if Tchaikovsky’s Fifth was given a reliably grand interpretation, it was Mr Kopatchinskaja’s revelatory performance of Schönberg’s Violin Concerto that remained most clearly etched in the memory.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.