Alemania
Resistance Anthems
The increasing threat of fascism in recent years has been a source of concern to anyone who follows the news, and it has not gone unnoticed in the opera house. The new production of Norma at the Staatsoper Unter den Linden – one of the key works in this year’s instalment of their Easter Festtage – was only the most recent staging to transplant a libretto set in ancient times into an uncomfortably familiar modern dystopia. Yet despite the intelligent and rigorously considered stage direction of Vasily Barkhatov, it was the incandescent vocal performances – notably those of Dmitry Korchak as Pollione and Rachel Willis-Sørensen in the title role – that gave the evening its sense of occasion.
Norma,
written to a libretto by Felice Romani, has one of those expertly-structured
narratives in which the outsized emotions of its principal characters render
the particularities of setting largely irrelevant. What drives the story is not
the struggle of oppressed Gauls against the conquering Romans, but the
friendship of Norma and Adalgisa, the caddish behaviour of Pollione, and the
way in which Norma’s wrath is transformed in the final moments into an
overwhelming selflessness; it is a libretto that is unapologetically structured
around the need for mesmerising arias, rousing duets and the occasional
highly-charged ensemble. It is, in short, an opera that would work equally well
in any setting in which a man of power and a woman of authority from opposite
sides of an ideological divide might find themselves consumed by an improper
passion.
In Vasily Barkhatov’s staging, the forests
of Gaul were replaced with a late-nineteenth or early-twentieth century factory
– the kind of glass-and-brick cathedral of industry that, in the present day,
tend to get converted into multi-purpose cultural venues – specialising in
the production of neo-classical statuary. During the overture, the workers of
the factory are overcome by invading soldiers, who set about repurposing the
factory to manufacture busts of the newly-installed military dictator. The
action of the opera proper opens ten years later, with the factory workers,
still under Norma’s direction, working reluctantly for the new regime while
secretly plotting its overthrow. With Pollione – who had ended up in an affair
with Norma years earlier – as the regime’s appointed overseer, and Adalgisa as
a younger worker who had more recently attracted Pollione’s roving eye, the
story required little alteration to fit snugly into its new setting. The
factory even had a large kiln just waiting to double for the funeral pyre on
which Norma would meet her eventual end.
If the oppressive life under fascism
provided a convincing frame for the story, Mr Barkhatov seemed less interested
in the political dimensions of his own construction than in the ramifications
of illicit love on its central characters. Indeed roughly half of the action
took place not in the grand central hall of the factory but in a small, spare
rooms in which the workers were quartered. These simple chambers, largely
devoid of fascist iconography, had a studied shabbiness that called to mind
neo-realist film or kitchen-sink drama, and their familiar squalour served to
place greater emphasis on the passions and dilemmas of the story’s central love
triangle than on its political context.
In fact Mr Barkhatov’s ability to present strongly
delineated characters was arguably more of an achievement than the
well-observed world he had created for them. His ease with large-scale scenes yielded
a number of memorable moments, especially the opening scene with its restless
conflict between workers and overseers, and the solemn ritual that played out
during the course of ‘Casta Diva’; the slow procession of workers as they
queued up to touch the few remaining relics of neo-classical statue had a hint
of Parsifal’s grail ceremony. But it was the scenes of subtly controlled
chamber drama that left the greater impression: Adalgisa’s confession to Norma
and the subsequent arrival of Pollione in the first act, and Norma’s one-on-one
confrontation with Pollione in the second – both scenes that can be played as
melodrama of the highest order – were rendered all the more compelling by means
of their (relative) emotional restraint.
In the best moments of the production Mr
Barkhatov’s direction offered a solid dramatic foundation for Bellini’s
displays of vocal brilliance; and while the principals remained firmly in
character throughout the evening, none of them forgot that Norma necessarily
succeeds or fails on the strength of its singing. Although it was announced at
the beginning of the evening that Dmitry Korchak was suffering from minor
illness, his Pollione was nonetheless a magnificent achievement. In his first
aria he matched elegant, unforced phrasing with a robust tone that one normally
encounters only on old LPs; his subsequent duet with Adalgisa was no less
captivating, a triumph of fluid line and emotional ardour. It is possible that
Pollione’s second act appearances would have been more monumental had Mr
Korchak been in full health, but his pleas for clemency in his final
confrontation with Norma were nonetheless delivered with arresting immediacy.
In the title role Rachel Willis-Sørensen
gave a performance that seemed to gather in intensity as it progressed. ‘Casta
Diva’ may be the opera’s most famous aria, but Ms. Willis-Sørensen approached
it less as a show-stopper than a crucial moment of character exposition, beginning
almost tentatively but building towards a conclusion of hypnotic grace. Indeed
her performance was notable for the way in which she was able to fold the
technical demands of the part into the dramatic contours of each scene: thus the
first act duet with Adalgisa – a scene that can survive perfectly well on the
beauty of its intertwined vocal lines – was given extra depth by its
undercurrents of emotional turmoil, while the first act finale and the second
act confrontation with Pollione thrived on Norma’s towering rage. Nor did Norma’s
climactic self-denouncement seem in any way implausible; even if it had, Ms.
Willis-Sørensen’s handling of the final scene – which, despite serious
competition, was possibly the evening’s finest moment – would have been
sufficient to remove any doubt.
As Adalgisa, Elmina Hasan found an
excellent balance between the meekness of the character and the expressive
emotions of the vocal part: she was credibly reluctant in her surrender to
Pollione, and she traced a convincing arc from uncertainty to assurance in the
excellent first act duet with Norma. Their duet in the second act was even
better, a beautifully crafted assertion of solidarity conveyed through the
gentle intermingling of voices. While the character of Oroveso was largely
peripheral to the staging, Riccardo Fassi had a strong opening scene and an
even stronger scene in the second act, placating the workers with elegance and
nobility.
The musical direction of Francesco
Lanzillotta was highly focussed and meticulously prepared, but also, at certain
moments, extremely wilful. The overture had an undeniable rhythmic charge, but
it was accompanied by a pursuit of exactitude that was never relaxed long
enough to allow Bellini’s flashes of grandeur to emerge. And while the action
of the first act moved forward at a compelling pace, a presiding restlessness
seemed occasionally to work against the natural rhythms of the vocal lines:
this was most evident in ‘Ah! bello a me retorna’, in which the innumerable
modifications in tempo, although perhaps tailored to the demands of the singer,
made the whole scene feel unsettled. A greater balance between tight control
and unforced phrasing emerged during the second act, and the duet between Norma
and Adalgisa – one of the evening’s high points – was all the more
arresting for its natural flow.
Despite its minimal plot – neither Bellini nor Romani saw the need to let convoluted sub-plots or an excess of back-story get in the way of a good duet – a well-cast Norma can sustain its length on the strength of vocal performances alone. While Vasily Barkhatov’s updated setting was wholly successful, and his command of character ensured that the individual scenes were driven by recognisably human drama, the finest moments of the Staatsoper’s new production belonged primarily to the singers.
Comentarios