Reino Unido

Crying for Butterfly

Enrique Sacau
Crying for Butterfly
Londres, lunes, 19 de febrero de 2007.
The Royal Opera House, Covent Garden. G. Puccini, Madama Butterfly. Moshe Leiser and Patrice Caurier, original production. Stephen Barlow, director. Christian Fenouillat, set designs. Agostino Cavalca, costume designs. Christophe Forey, lighting. Andrew Richards (B.F. Pinkerton), Martyn Hill (Goro), Elena Cassian (Suzuki), Alan Opie (Sharpless), Liping Zhang (Cio-Cio-San). The Royal Opera House Orchestra and Chorus. Renato Balsadonna, chorus master. Nicola Luisotti, conductor.
0,0001821 Last Saturday’s performance of Puccini’s Madama Butterfly at the Royal Opera House was preceded by some controversy, fuelled by Professor Roger Parker’s article ‘One fine obscenity’. Published by central-left newspaper The Guardian, Parker, a respected academic, stated that Butterfly is a good example of how opera can be racist and that the audience should be warned against its unacceptable content. I cannot disagree with Parker when he says that opera can be racist. I go even further: opera can also be male chauvinist or even justify terrorism (and if I were not currently working on an academic project about that I would give you examples of all this). This said, however, I am not sure whether Butterfly is a racist opera. On the contrary, as one reader of The Guardian said in his response to Parker, ‘Puccini doesn't make his audience feel good about [Pinkerton’s abandonment of Butterfly]. Far from being a work that offends modern sensibilities, Madama Butterfly shows how destructive cultural imperialism can be’. The funereal silence of the people leaving the auditorium on Saturday and the tears many of us shed seem to agree with this reader.




Liping Zhang
Photo © 2007 by Bill Cooper


Liping Zhang’s Butterfly should take part of the credit for our tears. Since I first saw her singing this role in 2003 she has improved considerably. The notes have always been there, yes, but her Butterfly is now more robust, if it has not lost a single touch of innocence. The best she gave us were floating sounds and long lyrical phrases. If she did not bring the theatre down with ‘Un bel dì vedremo’ is only because her final two notes in fortissimo were almost inaudible. All the rest was memorable, especially her final ‘Tu, tu, tu, piccolo Iddìo’.

Her Pinkerton was adequate. The fact that Andrew Richards is not the warmest of actors helped his character look aloof and indifferent to the suffering of his wife. His arrogance when he toasts to the day in which he marries a real American wife (‘al giorno in cui mi sposerò con vere nozze a una vera sposa americana’) was all the more real in his voice. Alan Opie’s rendition of the American consul, disgusted by the behaviour of his fellow citizen, showed his maturity and savoir faire. Elena Cassian’s outstanding Suzuki proves that she is ready to take on more demanding roles.

Nicola Luissoti returns to the Royal Opera after his successful debut with Il trovatore. Again, he has shown enormous ability to accompany the singers while making the orchestra portray the drama almost as a narrator. The sound of the orchestra and the chorus was full. I only hope, then, that ‘this is the beginning of a beautiful friendship’ between Luisotti and Covent Garden.



Liping Zhang
Photo © 2007 by Bill Cooper

Moshe Leiser’s and Patrice Caurier’s original production of Madama Butterfly, revived by Stephen Barlow and subtly lighted by Christophe Forey, is all about nuances. They individualise the characters with subtle gestures, poses and looks. They then wrap it in Christian Fenouillat’s simple and effective sets, a sort of minimalist, Japanese-like stage that works as a metaphor of Butterfly’s purity. Together with the singers’ and the conductor’s work, this production has helped Puccini make us cry again.
Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.