Alemania

Farewell Romanticism. Goodbye Tonality

Jesse Simon
Arnold Schoenberg
Arnold Schoenberg © OD
Berlin, domingo, 27 de octubre de 2013.
Philharmonie. Schönberg: Gurre-Lieder. Soile Isokoski, Tove; Karen Cargill, Waldtaube; Stephen Gould, Waldemar; Burkhard Ulrich, Klaus-Narr; Lester Lynch, Bauer; Thomas Quasthoff, Speaker. Rundfunkchor Berlin. MDR Rundfunkchor Leipzig. WDR Rundfunkchor Köln. Kor Vest Bergen. Berlin Philharmonic. Sir Simon Rattle, conductor. 50th Birthday celebrations for the Philharmonie
0,0001057

It is tempting to wonder what might have been, had Schönberg not abandoned the opulent romanticism of his early work in favour of the twelve-tone system with which he will be forever associated. In terms of music theory he would ultimately have been less influential, but his unique way with orchestral texture, dramatic gestures and large-scale constructions might nonetheless have resulted in some wonderful music. As it stands, our only window into this alternative world is Gurre-Lieder, a magnificent, unwieldy cantata with orchestral demands that eclipse even Mahler and a dense, chromatic sound-world that tests nineteenth-century romanticism to its breaking point.

The Berlin Philharmonic – who, just the weekend before, had marked the fiftieth birthday of their concert hall with a semi-staged performance of Bach’s Matthäus-Passion that used the space of the auditorium to unique effect – brought the Philharmonie’s week of anniversary celebrations to a close with a tremendous performance of Gurre-Lieder that utilised the auditorium in a very different way. If the Matthäus-Passion had been an exercise in using Hans Scharoun’s open-plan concert hall for minimalist stage-craft, Gurre-Lieder seemed more concerned with finding out exactly how many musicians that same hall could actually hold. The answer, it turns out, is a lot. With six vocal soloists, four choirs, four harps, countless horns and more strings than could possibly be on the payroll of a single orchestra, it was almost certainly the largest number of people one might ever see on stage in the service of a single work (with, perhaps, the honourable exception of Mahler’s Eighth ... although it would be a close call).

Such a mass of resources could easily spell trouble, but not for the Berlin Philharmonic, who seem perpetually capable of rising to meet the most ambitious and demanding of pieces; there are many orchestras in the world who can deliver a brilliant Beethoven’s Seventh, but considerably fewer who could navigate the complexities of Gurre-Lieder with such grace and clarity. For, despite the enormous resources necessary for a performance, the piece is a work of surprising subtlety, which frequently deploys its forces in smaller groups. The untamed beauty of the music is matched only by the discipline necessary to make it work.

Much of this discipline surely came from Sir Simon Rattle who, in general, seems to draw energy from larger orchestras and more complex scores (as demonstrated, for example, in his masterful performance of Boulez’s Notations last season). On this evening, Sir Simon, whose love of the piece was apparent in virtually every bar, directed a reading that was endlessly alert to the precise details of Schönberg score, but never afraid to take the work’s lustrous, almost ridiculous romanticism to its limit. Indeed, when an orchestra of that size gets whipped into a frenzy – as it was on several occasions, perhaps most notably in the orchestral interlude near the end of part one – the effect is exactly as overwhelming as Schönberg probably intended.

The fearsome orchestra was supported by an equally imposing choral ensemble – made up of members from no fewer than four different choirs – and a generally strong group of vocal soloists. The single most impressive vocal performance of the evening almost certainly belonged to Stephen Gould, who brought the full ardour of a heldentenor to the demanding role of Waldemar. Herr Gould – who is, incidentally, one of the more notable Tristans to come along in recent years – sang with the low-end warmth of a natural baritone in his quieter moments, but was also able to summon great reserves of lyrical passion. Not far behind him was the other tenor, Burkhard Ulrich, whose brief appearance as Klaus the Fool was effortless, expressive, and perfectly realised.

Of the other singers, Soile Isokoski brought wonderful phrasing to the songs of Tove, although the delicate nature of her performance was occasionally obscured by the swell of the large orchestra; and the smaller roles were also well handled, with Karen Cargill offering a mournful wood-dove and Lester Lynch providing a sturdy Peasant. Finally, Thomas Quasthoff brought his great feeling for drama to the role of the Speaker, delivering the text of ‘Des Sommerwindes wilde Jagd’ with a slowly mounting sense of excitement and wonder.

Indeed, there was a plenty to be excited about as the nocturnal hunt of Waldemar’s spirit-vassals gave way to the ecstatic sunrise that brings the piece to a close. Only in the final moments are we allowed to hear the mixed choir and the full orchestra all together at last … and what a sound they make. As convenient as it may be to listen to Gurre-Lieder on one’s home Hi-Fi, there is nothing that can compare with the all-encompassing physical sensation of sitting in the room where such a glorious sound is being created. As grand climaxes go, the end of Gurre-Lieder is almost impossibly grand and, in the best possible way, not a little overwhelming. If Schönberg devoted the rest of his life to smaller ensembles and unconventional approaches to harmony, it is perhaps because he realised he had taken his particular strand of epic tonality as far as it was possible to go.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.