Alemania
Famous Last Works
There can be few composers – with the possible exception of Mahler – who sat down with the intention of writing a last symphony or a final string quartet. Yet the idea of finality has an undeniable fascination; it confers an arbitrary privilege on those works which happened to be the last to emerge, and almost demands that we search within them for presentiments of death. It is this fascination that provided Sir András Schiff with the thematic structure for his recent series of recitals at the Kammermusiksaal; entitled ‘Last Sonatas’ the series presented the final three piano sonatas of Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven and Schubert over the course of three evenings.
If the four sonatas that made up the final concert of the series never quite conveyed the sense of great composers grappling with mortality, they nonetheless made for a programme that was both well-balanced and tremendously engaging. Rather than arrange the works chronologically, Sir András devised a programme of two halves in which Haydn’s good-natured E flat major sonata (Hob. XVI:52) was set against the transcendent majesty of Beethoven’s op. 111, and a compact work from Mozart (KV 576) acted as the prelude to Schubert’s panoramic final essay in sonata form (D 960). It was an intriguing arrangement, and its promise was realised in a series of performances that struck a perfect balance between idiosyncrasy and revelation.
There was nothing valedictory about the Haydn sonata that started the evening; composed some fifteen years before Haydn’s death, the piece possessed a lightness of spirit that was reflected in the exaggerated gestures and raised eyebrows that accompanied Sir András’ performance. Yet the jovial mannerisms that extended throughout the first movement were never directed at the audience. Sir András gave the impression of being locked in a dialogue with the music, reacting to it in real time with a mixture of surprise and delight.
The animation of his performance was underscored by an approach that favoured clean articulation over legato, and brief flashes of illumination over restrained continuity; his playing was full of pregnant pauses and sudden dynamic shifts that served to highlight Haydn’s themes, lest we should miss them. It was an approach that worked well in the first movement, but it resulted in a somewhat anxious second movement that seemed unable to settle into a natural flow. However the brisk, meticulous final movement was a delight, both technically and musically.
Of the four sonatas in the evening’s programme, it was Beethoven’s C minor sonata that conveyed its sense of finality most clearly. Sir András acknowledged the implicit gravitas of the work by sitting at the piano for what seemed like a very long time before playing a single note. When he did start, however, he produced a magnificently unconventional interpretation that, for all its idiosyncrasies, was perhaps the most extraordinary part of the evening. When one listens to Kempff or Pollini perform this work, one is aware of the music being drawn to its conclusion by some invisible, unstoppable force; in Sir András’ reading however, there was an uncertainty that was both surprising and thrilling. As the sonata unfolded, there was a sense that anything could happen.
There was plenty of the usual excitement in the first movement – a thunderous acceleration in the left hand led to an opening theme that was almost martial in its rhythmic insistence – but much of the drama came from the impression that Sir András was considering the implications of the music only seconds before playing the notes. While there was never any cause to doubt his technical command – the fine sense of articulation from the Haydn had carried over to the Beethoven – there was a measured quality to the emergence of the individual episodes that suggested an orator who has slowed the pace of their speaking to ensure they have enough time to think of exactly the right word.
The episodic quality of the first movement was enhanced, or perhaps complicated, by the sense that Sir András was making little attempt to impose a narrative onto the collection of ideas that Beethoven had assembled, but rather was going out of his way to stress the internal differences that most pianists would attempt to reconcile. This approach was even more pronounced in the second movement which, if occasionally disjointed, seemed to possess a constant flow of insight. But when the Arietta theme returned near the end of the movement, it occasioned some of the most lyrical playing we had heard all evening; and the C major chord that brings the sonata to its serene conclusion was all the more arresting for the fact that it seemed to come from out of nowhere. It struck us with the full power of its simplicity, and when one emerged from the auditorium it was with the sense of having experienced something extraordinary.
The second half of the programme opened with a performance of Mozart’s final sonata that would stand as the most straightforward part of the evening. The didactic approach that Sir András had adopted in the first half had almost completely disappeared; where he had spent the first two sonatas constantly highlighting and underlining, using barely perceptible pauses to emphasise what we had just heard, the Mozart sonata moved forward with calm assurance and a marked lack of conflict. Even his physical demeanour seemed more composed, with no sudden movements or changes in physical expression. The piece can be tremendously exciting, but in this performance it seemed merely pleasant.
It was, in any event, soon overshadowed by Schubert’s B flat major sonata. The piece, written only months before Schubert’s death, suggested a composer who had stretched the format to its limit, and in Sir András’ majestic performance it attained a grandeur that was almost symphonic. If the Beethoven was ultimately more moving, the Schubert was the more impressive performance.
Even in the opening bars, one could hear a difference. Not only was the tempo more urgent than anything we had heard that evening, but there was a greater fluidity in the playing, and a greater sense of the individual sections being part of some larger, if only vaguely perceptible structure. What was most impressive, however, was the scale of Sir András’ conception. When the opening theme made its grand reappearance a few moments into the piece, one could almost hear the sound of a full orchestra coming from the strings of the piano.
The second movement offered lyrical, searching melodicism perched atop a rhythmic foundation that was quietly insistent. By emphasising the repeating four-note figure that comes to the surface about halfway through, Sir András was able to infuse the movement with the very inevitability that had been absent from the Beethoven. The third movement on the other hand, was distinctly unemphatic, lively without being especially fast and rarely drawing attention to itself. Only in the final movement did the deliberate articulation of the evening’s first half reappear, bringing a grand sonata to a conclusion that was all the more effective for its shade of ambiguity. Certainly few pianists have made the chiming G – which opens the movement and returns several times throughout – sound more ominous.
As an encore, Sir András gave a spirited reading of the Menuets and Gigue from Bach’s B flat major Partita (BWV 825), a piece that is neither a sonata nor a final work, but which nonetheless provided a satisfying coda to the evening. If the collection and presentation of four last sonatas had not ultimately made a convincing argument about the significance of finality, the insights of a great pianist had given us a remarkable study of the possibilities offered by a single musical form.
Comentarios