Alemania

Musikfest 3: A Certain Restraint

Jesse Simon
Zubin Mehta
Zubin Mehta © Ibermúsica
Berlin, domingo, 6 de septiembre de 2015.
Philharmonie. Arnold Schönberg: Chamber Symphony No. 1, op. 9. Gustav Mahler: Symphony No. 9 in D major. The Israel Philharmonic Orchestra. Zubin Mehta, conductor
0,0002125

Zubin Mehta is no stranger to Berlin – he is both a frequent guest of the Berlin Philharmonic and an honorary conductor of the Staatskapelle – but it has been a number of years since he last visited with the Israel Philharmonic, the orchestra with whom he has long served as music director. It was therefore a pleasure to see them together on the stage of the Philharmonie as part of this year’s Musikfest, in a programme that included an exquisite performance of Schönberg’s first Chamber Symphony, followed by a quietly immaculate version of Mahler’s final completed symphony, the Ninth. 

The evening’s two works, composed within three years of one another, are both characterised by a certain restraint. In Pelleas und Melisande (to say nothing of the still-in-progress Gurre-Lieder), Schönberg had taken the size of the orchestra to its practical limit, and he seemed to realise that smaller was the only way to go. The first of his two chamber symphonies is scored for a mere fifteen musicians, although the intimacy of its forces ultimately serve to underscore the work’s larger ambitions. Indeed, when performed well – as it was on this evening – the smaller ensemble allows one to hear more clearly the restless invention of a composer searching for new paths away from traditional harmony. 

A recent knee operation made it necessary for Mr Mehta to conduct the evening sitting down, although this had no apparent effect on his ability to summon a series of highly involved performances from the fifteen instrumentalists. His reading, which seemed to possess an extraordinary insight into the work’s larger structure, did not attempt to play down the final traces of late romanticism still present in Schönberg’s style, but rather treated them as an essential point of departure. Even if the symphony represented a shift toward a more abstract form of expression, the performance never lost sight of the formal balance from which those abstractions derived. 

The fifteen soloists were generally superb, playing with considerable clarity and refinement; while the ten person woodwind-and-horn section possessed a sufficient weight, they never seemed in danger of overwhelming the five strings. Most importantly, the ensemble seemed so comfortable with the score that they were able to trade difficult phrases back and forth while adhering to the presiding rhythms that helped to bring the work’s unusual structure into focus. The resulting performance was a delight from beginning to end.

Mahler’s reduction of orchestral forces for his Ninth Symphony may not have been quite as severe, but the orchestra that took the stage for the second half of the programme seemed reasonably modest compared with the oversized ensemble that had performed the Sixth Symphony the evening before; even in formal terms, Mahler managed the reasonably rare (for him) feat of containing his symphony within four purely instrumental movements. What remained undiminished was the scale of his conception which, in the final movement of the evening’s performance, achieved an emotional depth that was all the more arresting for its subtlety. 

The first three movements, however, offered only a few hints of what was to come. This is not to say that there was anything out of place in the performance or anything lacking in the interpretation. Indeed, the quietly confident Mr Mehta seemed to possess the Kapellmeister’s self-effacing belief that, with a well-rehearsed orchestra and a strong score, the music will take care of itself. And for the most part it did. But while the first movement contained numerous passages of effortless magnificence, Mr Mehta’s lack of interest in over-sculpting the music could also produce occasional passages that sounded merely efficient. 

Nonetheless, it remained a difficult performance to fault. Although the orchestra experienced a few minor moments of muddiness during the some of first movement crescendi, they played for the most part with delicately restrained opulence. The horns and trombones were especially wonderful throughout, contributing a vastness to the full sound, while the final minutes of the first movement occasioned playing of great sensitivity from the oboes and flutes. 

Mr Mehta’s ability to make large or complex scores seem perfectly straightforward was on full display in the second movement, in which his sprightly, unforced pacing allowed the music to unfold with little apparent intervention. Only the third movement seemed a touch unbalanced, losing a few details in the rush of the outer sections, while simultaneously reining in some of the intemperate qualities that can make the make the movement genuinely thrilling; curiously, it was the quiet interlude near the end that proved to be the movement’s most affecting passage.

If the symphony had ended there, it would have been remembered as a fine, well-considered performance; but some mysterious, unseen process occurred in the few seconds separating the third and fourth movements. Indeed, the fourth movement seemed to exist in a world of its own. The assembled musicians sounded less like a full orchestra than a string quartet that had grown gigantic. The strings, with a heightened sense of purpose and richness of tone, played unaccompanied for several minutes and, when the bassoons and horns eventually joined them, it felt less like a strategy of orchestration than a natural extension of the movement’s primal sound. When the full orchestra swelled toward a climax, the sound retained its elegant simplicity; even a few hints of less-than-perfect intonation right at the end had little effect on the majesty radiating from the stage.  

According to the clock, the final movement lasted close to half an hour, but it was played with such intense concentration and such an assured grasp of structure that it seemed over in only a few minutes; yet at the end, one was conscious of having experienced something extraordinary, of having been brought very close to the heart of some great mystery only to be returned, at the end, to the familiar safety of the Philharmonie. Zubin Mehta and the Israel Philharmonic may not have set out in search of profundity but, in the final pages of Mahler’s Ninth Symphony, they managed to find it nonetheless. 

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.