Alemania

Late Arrivals

Jesse Simon
Dima Slobodeniouk
Dima Slobodeniouk © Festival de Música Cidade de Lugo
Berlin, jueves, 1 de febrero de 2018.
Philharmonie. Sibelius: Tapiola, op 112. Shostakovich: Violin Concerto No. 2 in C sharp major, op. 129. Prokofiev: Symphony No. 2 in D minor, op. 40. Baiba Skride, violin. Berlin Philharmonic. Dima Slobodeniouk, conductor.
0,0002166

When Dima Slobodeniouk last visited Berlin around two years ago, he led the Rundfunk-Sinfonieorchester on a spirited tour of youthful works by Shostakovich and Prokofiev. Both of those composers remained on the programme for his recent debut concert with the Berlin Philharmonic: Baiba Skride performed the solo part in an elegant, inwardly focused performance of Shostakovich’s second Violin Concerto, while Mr Slobodeniouk proved an intuitive guide through the less-familiar terrain of Prokofiev’s infrequently-performed Second Symphony. The two Russians were joined on this evening by Sibelius, whose Tapiola provided the evening with an enchanting prologue.

The Berlin Philharmonic have been responsible for several notable recordings of Tapiola, including one under Okko Kamu and no fewer than three under Herbert von Karajan; it thus came as something of a surprise to learn that they had not performed the work in concert since 1941. For its long overdue return, Mr Slobodeniouk crafted a tightly-coiled performance that cast aside the work’s dark majesty in favour of something more agitated and impulsive. The pace was brisk, but the rhythms emerged with a woozy fluidity, the violins danced with a jittery energy and the few intrusions of brass and timpani were genuinely arresting. Sibelius’ evocation of the forest spirit’s realm can often sound like a place of elemental stillness, but the forest conjured by Mr Slobodeniouk on this evening swarmed with elusive, omnipresent life.

For Shostakovich’s Second Violin Concerto, Mr Slobodeniouk and the orchestra remained very much in the service of Baiba Skride, who established herself as the driving force behind a thoughtful, entrancing performance. Her first appearance, rising from a bed of gently ominous basses, was mellow in tone and calm in manner. Although she grew more incisive in her attack as the piece progressed, she seemed largely uninterested in expressions of impassioned anguish. Instead of highlighting the contrasts in the violin part, she was able to penetrate to the heart of the work through measured insistence; in the complex first movement cadenza there were no grand flourishes, but her quiet assurance revealed no lack of internal drama.

What was most impressive about Ms Skride’s performance was the conviction she brought to the different modes and guises of the solo part; it was not simply her ability to move from understated lyricism to bow-shredding intensity, but her ability to make those individual moments of expression feel natural and self-contained. As she made her way through the exquisitely phrased song-like passages at the beginning of the slow movement, the swirling solo section accompanied only by the timpani, and the sharply articulated lines of the third movement’s Rondo theme, even the most sudden transitions seemed wholly unforced. Mr Slobodeniouk coaxed a buoyant, idiomatic performance from the orchestra that remained largely deferential to Ms Skride’s concentrated playing.

Prokofiev’s Second Symphony, like Tapiola, has been recorded by the Berlin Philharmonic (in the early nineties under Seiji Ozawa) but, according to the programme booklet, there are no records of any concert performances. It is, in many ways, a chaotic, uncontained work; its most frenzied moments never seem to be balanced by the sneaky melodic accessibility found in his better-known symphonies. Yet there is much to enjoy in the Second – not least the elegant theme that sets the second movement in motion, and the structure of the whole, which follows closely the design of Beethoven’s Piano Sonata op. 111 – and Mr Slobodeniouk proved an excellent guide to its oddities and intricacies.

The second movement was generally more successful than the first, which in its loudest moments suffered from a convincingly huge but slightly undifferentiated sound. Instead of moderating between the various sections of the orchestra, Mr Slobodeniouk seemed to be riling them up and setting them against one another. The trumpets banded together to rise above the strings, who played with a ferocity that had not and would not be encountered elsewhere in the evening. Mr Slobodeniouk’s ability to suggest a logic at the heart of such outward volatility was impressive, and the exertions of the orchestra were certainly not lacking in excitement, but the whole thing left one more exhausted than exhilarated.

After the trumpets of the first movement had died away, the strings grew softer and warmer and the emergence of the second movement theme in the woodwinds managed to dispel much of the preceding tension. If the opening had offered flashes of beauty amidst the fury, even the wildest moments of the subsequent variations seemed anchored in graceful restraint. In the opening bars, Mr Slobodeniouk’s tempi were not especially relaxed – even the meditative Larghetto of the fourth variation was nudged forward with a hint of urgency – but his sense of each variation’s particular character, and its function within the structure of the whole, allowed the movement to unfold with considerably more equanimity.

The excitability of the first movement hadn’t disappeared, but had been harnessed and deployed more exactingly. In the third and fifth variations, the taut rhythms provided a foundation for dynamic, detailed micro-dramas, while the fourth used its gentle insistence to build itself into an almost trance-like state. Even in the final variation, which culminated in a heavy stomp over which the horns and high strings were just able to rise, there was a devastating precision far removed from the untamed first movement.

The Second is less a conventional symphony than the record of a struggle; one can hear Prokofiev wrestling with the might of the orchestra while simultaneously testing for himself the bounds of symphonic form. It was a work he needed to get out of his system before moving onto other works, and this alone may explain why it has never secured a place in the standard repertoire. Yet while it may remain something of a rarity, it is certainly not negligible and, on this evening at least, it was a pleasure to spend time in the presence of such a well-considered performance.

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.