Alemania

Musikfest 4: Two Viennese Schools

Jesse Simon
Musikfest 4: Two Viennese Schools
Berlin, jueves, 10 de septiembre de 2015.
Kammermusiksaal. Beethoven: String Quartet in F major, op. 135. Webern: Three Pieces for String Quartet and Voice. Berg: Lyric Suite. Schönberg: String Quartet No. 2, op. 10. Barbara Hannigan, soprano. Emerson String Quartet. Berlin Musikfest 2015
0,0002176

Vienna can lay some legitimate claim to being the ancestral home of the string quartet. Haydn brought the form to maturity, Beethoven elevated it to perfection, and numerous other composers associated with the Austrian capital – notably Mozart and Schubert – produced exceptional contributions to the genre. After Beethoven, however, the string quartet went into something of a holding pattern. Brahms, Schumann and even Bruckner each composed a handful, while Mendelssohn and Dvorák wrote larger cycles; but it was not until the dawn of the twentieth century that the form was again embraced for its uncharted musical possibilities. Once more, it was Viennese composers who formed the vanguard. 

It was this implicit gap between Beethoven and the Second Viennese School – along with the relationship between the string quartet and the sung or spoken word – that formed the theme of a recent concert given by the Emerson String Quartet as part of this year’s Musikfest. Beethoven’s final quartet – the F major, op. 135, with its great unspoken ‘Muß es sein?’ / ‘Es muß sein!’ dialogue – was used to introduce a trio of works by Webern, Berg and Schönberg, each of which supplemented the standard quartet arrangement with the sound of the human voice (provided, on this evening, by the fearless Barbara Hannigan). It was an inspired programme that seemed to play directly to the strengths of its performers. 

Of Beethoven’s late quartets, the op. 135 is arguably the most modest, and certainly the most compact, a joyous four movement work with a notable absence of grand fugues or monumental songs of thanksgiving. Yet the work should not be undervalued; even if the ‘difficult decision’ of the final movement suggests an existential weight that never materialises, there is nothing facile about its apparent good nature. The Emersons made no attempt to overburden the most genial passages – the sharply defined rhythms of the second movement unfolded with a natural verve, and the Allegro section of the fourth was positively exuberant – yet they seemed to derive the greatest delight in drawing out the undercurrents of solemnity. 

The precision and resolve of the playing was often dazzling. In the most frenzied passages of the second movement, the notes were so cleanly articulated that one could almost see them on the printed page while, in the third movement, the unity of the ensemble summoned a mood of intense reverence coupled with a generously proportioned sound. Yet the brilliance of the playing seemed occasionally to mask a certain intellectual distance, as if the process of sounding so light-hearted was something of a chore. 

It was, of course, a fine performance, and impressive for its technical mastery. But there could be no doubt that, when the quartet returned – accompanied this time by Ms Hannigan – there was a completely different level of engagement emanating from the stage. Their first offering was a striking, meditative account of a piece that was over almost before it began. Webern’s unpublished Three Pieces for String Quartet and Voice – the two instrumental pieces were later incorporated into the Six Bagatelles op. 9 – uses two highly condensed fragments to bookend a setting of a text by the composer. The whole thing did not last more than three minutes, but Ms Hannigan’s hypnotic performance, which concluded with a stunning diminuendo, somewhat offset its brevity. 

However it was Berg’s more substantial Lyric Suite that would stand as the evening’s high point. The suite, written exactly a century after Beethoven’s op. 135, opened with an Allegretto that was arresting for its commanding pace, its elegant animation and, perhaps most importantly its sincerity of feeling. If the Beethoven had occasionally seemed like a display of virtuosity, the heightened technical demands of the Lyric Suite occasioned playing of far greater wit and passion; and the same inspiration that illuminated the first movement continued throughout the piece. In the Andante, the Emersons managed to locate a genuine suspense in Berg’s surprising turns of phrase, while in the astonishing third movement, they moved effortlessly between agitated swarms, charged pizzicato and slippery passages that traced precarious paths along the highest limits of the instruments. 

The final three movements pursued an increasing severity, moving from darkness to anguish to eventual despair. Yet the forceful passions of the fifth movement were never overwrought; and in the sixth, the quartet was joined once again by Ms Hannigan, who sung an intensely dramatic lament – a setting of Baudelaire – that showcased the supple lower extent of her vocal range. There were equal amounts of passion, mystery and desolation in her performance, supported by playing of tremendous sensitivity. 

The obvious precursor to the final movement of the Lyric Suite would have been Schönberg’s Second string quartet, which formed the second half of the evening’s programme. The quartet, which features two instrumental movements followed by two settings of poems by Stefan George, was composed almost twenty years earlier and may have been the first piece to add a human voice to the four strings. On this evening the Emersons and Ms Hannigan gave a performance that came very close to matching the Lyric Suite in both precision and emotional involvement. 

Both the first and second movements were played with the same mixture of concentration and articulation that the quartet had already displayed in the evening’s finest moments: to the first movement they added undertones of subtle longing, while the second alternated an intense rhythmic focus with probing passages that searched without meandering. In final two movements Ms Hannigan delivered expressive readings of the two George poems, Litanei and Entrückung; although the high sustained notes with their controlled vibrato were undeniably impressive, it was the lower, quieter passages that proved the most mesmerising. The opening line of the fourth movement in particular achieved a maximum of presence with a minimum of volume.

In the decades since Schönberg, Berg and Webern, the string quartet has captured the imagination of numerous composers and has been used as a means of realising countless musical ideas; and while Schönberg’s second string quartet (with it’s genre-defying addition of the soprano voice) and Berg’s Lyric Suite (with its unconventional yet deeply satisfying structure) may once have been viewed as radical, the captivating performances on this evening – as well as the enthusiastic audience reception – suggested that the pieces were well on their way to becoming, in their own way, as classic as Beethoven. 

Comentarios
Para escribir un comentario debes identificarte o registrarte.